Skip to content

A good night’s sleep means no commitments

Published:

By LEGAL NEWS & VIEWS BY DAVID PISARRA

C ontinuing with last week’s essay on a real world example of how to build a business, this week I explain how we arrived at some of our numbers. We knew that we had certain fixed costs, such as rent, staffing costs, a tax burden on the staff, utilities, equipment leasing, marketing materials and administration costs. We also wanted to make sure that we weren’t locked in to any long-term contracts as part of our exit strategy.

When reviewing estimates, what you need to always be aware of is whose estimate it is, and what are their personal motivations and goals. Entrepreneurs in the full rush of enthusiasm of a new venture will always overestimate their sales and underestimate their costs. On the flip side, the investor will almost always do the reverse, and overstating the expenses and underestimating the sales. Their motivations are important here — for the entrepreneur is an optimist and the investor is “being conservative.”

Of course, the other reason for the investors to use lower numbers is that the value of the company is based on the projections, and that directly impacts what the investor receives for their investment. This is also why the entrepreneur wants to make the company look bigger, that way they can sell less of the company for more money.

When it comes to ‘guesstimating’numbers, it is safer and better for all concerned to follow the investor’s approach. You have a greater chance of success if you have overbudgeted your costs and underestimated your income.

For our sleep-testing company, the first projection was based on a hospital providing us with rent-free space in their unused rooms. We only need three rooms to get started and, since we would actually be a service provider to the hospital and increase their revenue, when it came to ancillary services we offer, this would not be unimaginable. This is a good scenario, and would have dramatically increased our bottom line, being rent-free. However, it did not provide us with the quick “time to market” that we wanted, since medical bureaucracies are renowned for being slow moving, and we found that to still be the case. Additionally, the business model we ended up with has the sleep lab in a resort-type hotel which more closely mimics a person’s actual sleep environment.

The hotel setting allows us greater flexibility in our facilities, even though we had to negotiate a long-term lease with a hotel, which consisted of several short-term periods that provided us with options to extend our stay.

Part of our exit strategy is having the ability to get out of our commitments quickly and cleanly. This meant negotiating the push/pull of security versus flexibility. On the one hand, we want a long-term contract with the hotel to know that we won’t have to move anytime soon. On the other hand, if we have no clients, I want us to be able to get out of the hotel and our equipment leases quickly. This meant we ended up doing business in basically six-month increments.

Because we are in a hotel we don’t need to worry about utility costs, but we do have a phone cost and Internet costs. These we budgeted for high, because when you are starting a business you will spend a great deal of time on the phone drumming up business. This included cell phones, fax machines and long-distance charges for 800 numbers. Then there was the equipment — phone equipment is purchased, but diagnostic is leased.

Equipment leasing was a big deal. Every new business wants to lease equipment, and not have a long-term contract that they are committed to, which is also personally guaranteed by the owners. Every equipment lessor wants long-term leases and will not do anything without a personal guarantee. Thus, a dilemma arises.

For us, that meant that we wanted, and would not sign, a long-term equipment lease. Our equipment cost is $100,000, but I’m not going to buy it. I will lease it, but only for a short time. Six months was the longest lease I was willing to sign. We were able to negotiate hard, and with a couple of back-end options, we achieved a very favorable lease for our purposes.

Staffing is always a major expense of any new business. We had to plug in costs for high-level technicians, low-level technicians, administration people and marketing people. All of them have different rates, and depending on how much we used each one, and their position with the company — whether full time or part time — also affected their tax cost to us. We used a 20-percent tax burden for our salaried personnel. This is a crucial area and one that is frequently forgotten by new entrepreneurs. They look at the number of staff they have decided they need, and multiply by the rate, and use that as their “staff costs,” but doing so will not show the tax burden of state and federal taxes, administration costs, payroll processing and bookkeeping costs. It is a small detail that can quickly become a big item.

Our technicians have three levels and three pay rates. The entry-level sleep technician earns between $13 and $19 an hour. The high-level techs earn between $20 and $25 per hour. Then there is the manager position, which is salaried, who oversees the scheduling, hiring, firing and general administration of the technicians. That position will have a base salary, plus employer tax burden, plus any benefits.

When considering staffing cuts, hourly employees have the most dramatic and immediate relief to payroll without killing a position. We can cut back on hours and not have to lose a person who is trained when times are tight. This cannot be done with a salaried person. They are either on or off, for the duration. Thus, to be on the safe side we projected a high pay rate for our technicians, so that we would have enough room to tighten our belts if we needed to later. This also increased the tax burden calculation, but we would have “wiggle room” if we needed it.

Part of any good business plan is having a worst-case scenario planned out. We needed to know what we were locked into paying and to whom. Having an exit plan, means considering the downside. More on that next week. (David Pisarra is a business development lawyer in the Santa Monica firm of Pisarra & Grist. He welcomes your questions and comments. He or 310/664-9969.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 15, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe