Skip to content

A letter to Afghanistan: A different perspective

Published:

By John Marciano

C. Bradley Thompson’s “open letter to the people of Afghanistan” (SMDP, Dec. 25, page 4) is an arrogant and deeply flawed statement on U.S. history and the Constitution. Those now writing a new constitution in Afghanistan should ignore his advice and reject the model set forth by the Founding Fathers that Thompson elevates to heroic status. Space does not permit a critique of his entire commentary; therefore, I will only address his major assertions on the U.S. political system and the Constitution.

Thompson tells those in Afghanistan that they must “confront and overcome” their own history. This principle applies to the United States as well. When white European settlers invaded this land, there were hundreds of independent, self-governing Indian nations with their own languages, cultures and political practices. One, the League of the Iroquois in what is now the Northeast United States that embraced the Cayuga, Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, and Seneca nations, had a far more egalitarian political structure than that which emerged in the Constitution — especially when it came to gender relationships. In his “Red, Black and White,” historian Gary Nash found that in the League “power was shared between the sexes and the European idea of male dominancy and female subordination … was conspicuously absent in Iroquois society.” Women had important powerful and fundamental roles in governing the Iroquois and other Indian nations, in contrast to their total political absence in the U.S. Constitution that Thompson celebrates.

Thompson makes it appear that the Bill of Rights were an essential and important part of the genius of the Founding Fathers, but the truth is that these important rights were opposed by the constitutional delegates. The first 10 amendments to the Constitution were added later by Congress when it responded to criticism from the public when the document was presented for ratification. If the Founding Fathers had their way, we would not have had a Bill of Rights in the Constitution.

In “A People’s History of the United States,” historian Howard Zinn asserts that the Constitution put in place by the Founding Fathers legitimized the inferior position of black people, excluded Indians, and established the supremacy of the rich and powerful. Thompson and others would have us believe that this document “was a work of genius put together by wise, humane men who created a framework for democracy and equality,” the main-stream view that most of us learned in schools. Historian Charles Beard’s “An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution,” however, reveals that the Founders — all white males — left out most of the population, including slaves, indentured servants, women, and men without property, when they created the document. Does Thompson want the new Afghan constitution to follow such a model of “democracy?”

Zinn believes that “when economic interest is seen behind the political clauses of the Constitution, then the document becomes not simply the work of wise men trying to establish a decent and orderly society, but the work of certain groups trying to maintain their privileges...” The Constitution has lasted because it has reflected the interests and privileges of the ruling class in U.S. history; progressive changes came about later as a result of popular struggles for democracy and freedom, and catastrophic events such as the Civil War that led to the Reconstruction amendments to the original document.

The Founding Fathers so enamored of democracy and freedom included a number of slave owners and other wealthy individuals who had no patience with the idea that the people could govern themselves without rule from above by an elite. It took political struggles to eliminate property restrictions against voting, the above-mentioned Civil War carnage and Reconstruction amendments, labor-union agitation, feminist suffrage efforts, and human-rights activists in the south in the 1950s and 1960s to bring the about the “genius” of democracy that Thompson asserts emerged in 1789. All these progressive changes were opposed by the ruling class and its intellectual apologists, who have never been committed to “inalienable rights” for all.

Thompson’s admiration for John Locke as a symbol of Western enlightenment thought and a model for the Founding Fathers is quite instructive. Locke wrote the Fundamental Constitutions for the Carolinas in the 1660s. Zinn points out that Locke “set up a feudal-type aristocracy, in which eight barons would own 40 percent of the colony’s land, and only a baron could be governor.” These barons included slave owners. This is the racist and real John Locke, not the idealized version that we learned about in government and philosophy classes, the committed democrat Thompson would have us admire. Locke was a wealthy man who made his fortune in investments from the silk trade and slave trade, and he followed his class and racial self-interest.

Thompson would also have us believe that the Founding Fathers, who owned slaves and proclaimed that cruel institution’s legitimacy, were going to lead us to the “moral foundations and the political institutions necessary to establish a free and just society.” He also claims “through our revolutionary experience we learned that the protection of man’s individual rights is the only legitimate function of government.” Evidently that protection did not extend to those who were owned by others, women, the poor, and Indians whose lives and land were destroyed by the United States. Thompson celebrates a Constitution that legitimized genocide against America’s first citizens and inhabitants, documented by hundreds of treaty violations and massacres, including the scorched earth campaign of General Sullivan against the Cayuga Nation in Upstate New York, my former home, under direct orders from General Washington.

If we examine the actual historical record, as opposed to the fairy tale that Thompson weaves, we must reject each and every assertion he arrogantly aims at the people of Afghanistan. They have suffered far too long to listen to the lies and myths that he parades forth. (John Marciano, a resident of Santa Monica, is professor emeritus, State University of New York at Cortland, and former chair of the Ithaca, New York Human Rights Commission, 1991-96).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 31, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe