I wrote and studied in Jerusalem, Palestine and Israel for about three years or so. After reading some of the letters you’ve received about Palestinians and Israelis, I have to humbly offer this in balance. If all we do is perpetuate the rhetoric of past years then we contribute to the hate that already exists. Palestinians are not pigs. Israelis aren’t either.
F.Y.I.: ■ Before there was The Jerusalem Post newspaper there was The Palestine Post from 1932-1950. I believe this speaks to a sense of national identity that some say never existed. ■ There was and has been Jewish terrorism — the Haganah, the Palmach, Lehi, the Stern Gang, the Irgun. Research Lidda, or Deir Yassin. The Palestinians learned from some of the best — British and Jewish terrorists.
This is history. Have you ever heard of Plan Dalet or Gush Emunim? There’s also been terrorism against Christians in Israel, committed by Jews, since 1948. This too, is documented. Have you ever heard the Christian right wing in the United States talk about this? I’ve decided to call myself a follower of Christ now instead of Christian. I don’t believe that Jesus was prejudiced. ■ Read The Birth of Israel by Simha Flappan. He talked about the founding myths of the State of Israel. It is a powerful book. I’ve read he died just before it was published. ■ There are Jews in Israel who do not believe that the Israel of God can be created by the hand of man, plainly stated, they don’t believe in the State of Israel. Whether it was theater or not, they marched alongside Palestinians at Durban. This is a guess but I believe there are Jewish people who are tired of their faith being used. I heard somewhere that they call themselves the Hebrew nation. Who may be perpetuating/funding “holy wars” that don’t exist and who is profiting? Exactly who is lying? ■ Israel is not a member of the UN. I saw a sign that read: UN = “Unwanted Nobodies” on a settler-owned, black SUV in Jerusalem. Think of Iran, Iraq and all the other countries bound by treaties they’ve signed relating to nuclear weapons. Seems convenient. Who is Israel’s biggest supporter? Where do they get most of their funding? From the United States government and the Christian right in the US. Cumulatively, it is nearly $1 billion each year. Give this some thought. ■ Israel is primarily an intelligence and police training ground (CIA, Mossad, FBI, Shinn Beit, etc). Perhaps they train the world’s police or monitor the world’s communications systems there. From what I witnessed over the three-year period I was there, it seemed that way to me. It would give them something to hide wouldn’t it? Israel has been called Silicon Wadi — like Silicon Valley. Think of satellite controlled, mind-control weaponry, microwave harassment, laser-guided weaponry, etc. ■ There are young people who now refuse to serve in the Israeli military. ■ Under aliyah or the right of return, Jews from all over the world who are or have been intelligence in their own countries can meet in Israel without being questioned. It seems pretty simple, convenient and hidden in plain sight. Give this some thought. ■ Israel has a nuclear weapons program. From what I’ve read, it’s centered beneath Tel Aviv and has been for a long time. I read this in textbooks — it’s not a secret. Vanunu could probably tell you, now that he’s out of prison. I think of Gaza, the over 2 million people (a UN figure) who live there and it worries me. ■ Hamas received funding from Israel. Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden received money from the United States government. I find myself asking who the real terrorists are. ■ There are Jewish, Israeli and Palestinian people who work for peace. How often do you hear about them in the United States? What part has the US government played in perpetuating the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? ■ Israeli Jews fight between themselves. Sephardim and Ashkenazim. This isn’t a secret either; it’s in the Israeli press. Research Ethiopian Jews and their current place in Israeli society.
My concern is for the people in the middle — those Palestinians and Israelis who don’t want to be part of the lies that are perpetuated there. Those who want peace.
While I was there, there were times when I wondered if some of the events that were being reported were/are real, or simply theater. Israel and the United States have a lot to protect. Journalist Martin Bell wrote in “In Harm’s Way, Reflections on a War Zone Thug” this passage, “The Croats were campaigning for international recognition and it suited their purpose to be seen fighting off the marauding Serbs. Coincidence or conspiracy? Did the battle occur just while we were there or because we were there?” There were times when I wondered the same thing about some of the events reported in Israel.
Terrorist bombings, shootings, etc. If we weren’t there at the sight of the bombing or attack, how can we really be sure? I heard a reported bombing once, but I never saw one and I walked almost everywhere when I was in Jerusalem. I know how harsh that sounds but if you had lived there, I believe you may wonder, too.
No, I am not anti-semitic. I am concerned for all of the people who live there and have no control over their own future or lives.
I’ve been the target of international abuse myself for the past two and a half years, including here in Santa Monica and Venice. It is ugly and cruel.
I’m not sure if it’s because I am a follower of Christ, because I worked for a Palestinian organization, because I worked for, and wrote about peace, because of what I saw or didn’t see, or simply because I try to see the best in people, regardless of who they were or where they come from. I helped out at both Palestinian and Jewish organizations in Jerusalem, Palestine and Israel, including the English speak-
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 9, 2004. Read the original PDF.