California’s libraries
By GUEST COMMENTARY BY STEPHEN KRASHEN
A government survey of public libraries released last month (“Public Libraries in the United States: Fiscal year 2003”) shows that California’s public libraries are in bad shape.
According to the survey, we rank 37th among all states in terms of book holdings with 2.3 books per capita. Maine, No. 1, provides more than double this amount — 5.2 books per capita. California public libraries are even worse off in audio materials, ranking 43rd, and we rank 38th in video and magazine holdings.
California public libraries have 2.5 librarians per 25,000 state residents, putting us in 45th place (New Hampshire has 8.3 librarians per 25,000 people, more than triple California’s figure.) These results are not new. Last year’s “America’s Most Literate Cities” report from the University of Wisconsin ranked the library systems of 79 U.S. cities. Oakland ranked 51st, Long Beach, 64th; Fremont, 65th; Fresno, 69th; Los Angeles, 73rd; Anaheim, 78th; and Santa Ana 79th. Only San Francisco (34th) and San Jose (39th) escaped the bottom one-third.
California also neglects its school libraries, spending a pathetic 3 percent of the national average. California school libraries have the fewest books per child in the United States, and by far the fewest credentialed school librarians — one per 4,500 students. The national average is one per 900 students.
We should be concerned. Studies confirm that the quality of both school and public libraries are related to how well children read. It is no surprise that California has the lowest reading scores in the nation, and has been last since 1992, the first time scores for individual states were analyzed.
Children of poverty typically do poorly on reading tests, and they are the most dependent on libraries because they have the least access to books at home.
“When I read about the way in which library funds are being cut and cut, I can only think that American society has found one more way to destroy itself.” — (Isaac Asimov, from his autobiography I Asimov)
About 35 to 40 percent of circulation of public library materials is child-related.
What is to be done?
There are three major sources of funding for public libraries. State governments contribute about 10 percent of library budgets nationally, about 80 percent comes from local (community, district, region) funding, and about 6.5 percent comes from “other” sources (donations, interest, library fines, fees, grants). The federal contribution is negligible, about one half of 1 percent nationwide.
Much of California’s shortfall comes from the state. We are only slightly below average when it comes to local support, about 97 percent of the national average, but the state invests less than half — 45 percent — of the national average in public libraries. Also, California libraries were only able to come up with 67 percent of the national average in terms of “other” contributions to the library budget.
If California just wanted to be average, to spend as much per capita on public libraries as other states do, it would have to spend another $125 million per year. If the state were to pay its share, it would have to invest another $66 million, making up about half the shortfall. We are even farther behind when it comes to school libraries. Adding $129 million to the current allotment of $4 million for school libraries would bring us to the national average.
For a total increase of about $254 million, we would be spending as much as the average state does on its public and private libraries. That’s only about a third of 1 percent of the $90 billion state budget.
Contrary to popular opinion, nearly all children in the United States master the basics of reading. Some do it faster than others, but they all manage, eventually, to read at least at a basic level. There are few total illiterates who have been to our public schools. To get beyond the basic level, however, children need access to books, and for many children, libraries are their only chance.
Instead of making pious pronouncements about raising levels of literacy and investing more in measuring the problem (increased testing), California might consider making the most obvious investment and spend a third of 1 percent of the state budget, or more, on libraries. (Stephen Krashen is a professor emeritus at the University of Southern California.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 15, 2005. Read the original PDF.