Skip to content

A week in wilderness displays uncompassionate conservatism

Published:

By Ed Silverstein

I spent the past week with a group of conservatives. The setting was Togiak River Fishing Lodge in Alaska (which I highly recommend) where the guests competed with grizzly bears, otters and eagles to catch the seemingly endless stream of silver (coho) salmon heading up river to spawn.

As we shared a common passion, an easy camaraderie was quickly achieved among the guests. As a group, these mostly older, educated, well-to-do men (and one woman) were friendly, helpful and full of laughter. But to my dismay a good many of them were also surprisingly ignorant and selfish.

One of the men, traveling with his father, lived in Alaska and had recently sold his environmental consulting firm. I was interested in what he thought about drilling in the Arctic wilderness. He was all for it. He felt that there was little chance of a spill and the impact of one would not be significant enough to warrant not drilling.

But then his motivations became clearer. He was concerned because there had been some talk about initiating a state income tax in Alaska. He was strongly opposed to such a tax and felt that there would be no need if they opened up the wilderness to drilling. But then in the next breath he advocated eliminating the permanent fund that provides a small sum to all permanent residents of Alaska. He would also eliminate additional payments made to the native population, most of whom live in abject poverty, struggle with alcoholism and suicide, and have almost no means to make a living.

Many of these Alaskans depend on these extra dollars to survive. But this man, this multi-millionaire who has his own plane, who had just returned from a month vacation in Hawaii and was now spending nearly $8,000 to take his father fishing, wanted to eliminate these payments so he wouldn’t have to pay a few dollars in state tax, the necessity of which was, no doubt, caused by Bush’s tax cuts. Tax cuts he completely supports.

While he didn’t venture an opinion about global warming, his father, a retired pharmacist, was certain that it didn’t exist. How did he know this? Rush Limbaugh said it was all a liberal plot.

Let us pretend for a moment that Rush Limbaugh is more than just a coarse, loud, vile, slimy, duplicitous, wind bag who is willing to say anything, regardless of its veracity, in order to advance the poor hating, minority hating, liberal hating, business-loving neo-conservative movement. And let’s also pretend that this mentally challenged ideologue had some actual educational qualification for having an opinion that was in direct opposition to about 85 percent of the world’s greatest scientists in the field. And let’s even pretend that the glaciers that are all melting, the fish populations that are dwindling or moving north, the ocean temperatures that are rising and the heat waves that are multiplying are just a cyclical fluctuation. What if Rush is right and nearly everybody else is wrong? What if, in our misguided “liberal” zeal, we made businesses more responsible for pollution, demanded improved gas mileage for cars and trucks, developed alternative and renewable energy sources and pushed conservation?

Well, the air would be cleaner which might result in fewer childhood and senior respiratory problems. We would save lots of money on gas as demand would be down and cars would operate cheaper. We would not have to ruin pristine wildernesses, regardless of how insignificant the possibility of an ecological disaster. And we would not be dependent upon human rights violating, Mid East dictators. Plus, the creation and production of new technologies would provide many well-paying jobs for the unemployed.

But what if Rush is wrong? Our environment will continue to get hotter and dirtier. We will have increasing temperatures in the ocean and huge fish kills, as well as the loss of many other species. The polar icecaps will melt. Weather patterns will be thrown into chaos. There will be worldwide droughts and flooding. The ozone layer will probably become increasingly depleted and skin cancer rates will explode. Water shortages and crop failures in much of the world will kill millions or even billions of people. Is it worth taking the chance? The pharmacist thought it was.

And as long as we’re on the subject of Rush, a relative of mine recently informed my wife that the reason the media is liberal and immoral is because Jews run Hollywood. And guess where she heard it? Not only isn’t it true, but statements such as these bear such a remarkable resemblance to the tactics used by the Nazis that we should consider giving Limbaugh an-all-expense paid trip to Nuremberg. And if my conservative relative is really so concerned with morality, she might want to break up with her married boyfriend before their kids find out. And for the record, the media is about as liberal as Joseph McCarthy.

Also at the lodge was a rice farmer from Sacramento. He supported driver licenses for illegal immigrants and for a moment I thought he might even be liberal. “Yup,” he went on to say. “I want all those wetbacks to get licenses so that our insurance rates will go down.” Of course he had no problem with illegal aliens; hires them all the time.

The farmer hated welfare, which he blamed on the Democrats — unaware that welfare reform had been consecrated under Clinton. And while he denigrated all “those lazy bastards who lived off his hard work” and railed against “women who dropped kids by the truckload just so they can up their welfare payments,” he had no problem accepting his share of the massive farm subsidies. His Sacramento rice grower cooperative collects over $28 million a year or about the same as 1,500 welfare recipients. And with the help of this corporate welfare he’s expanding his farm just so he can collect even more welfare.

The farmer also hated the idea of any sort of health coverage for the poor. He, like many of the guests, seemed to believe that these people needed to work harder so they could afford health coverage. His opinion was that, “If he could do it, they could do it.” Of course, it is a lot easier to do “it” when you inherit a successful farm from your father. I explained that many of these “lazy” immigrants were working three jobs just to get by and that if they got sick they couldn’t pay their bills and were forced to give up necessities. He was unsympathetic. He had had bad years in the past and had been forced to give up necessities, too … like his country club membership. Yes, he actually said that.

In talking to people such as these, what I have come to understand is that what is glaringly missing from compassionate conservatism is the compassion. That is not to say that all conservatives are like this. But the neo-conservatives in power today have made it OK to be selfish, to be racists, to despise the poor and blame them for their condition. For a group that never loses an opportunity to quote Christ or promote Christian values, they seem to be missing the point.

ASIDE 1: As reported in The New Republic, Democrats, bowing to pressure from the high tech sector, are pressuring the Federal Accounting Standards Board not to adopt mandated stock-option expensing, a key element to corporate reform. Further, the Dems chose to appoint Robert Lenhard over the incumbent Scott Thomas to the Federal Election Committee.

While Thomas supported campaign finance reform, Lenhard will likely do what he can to undermine McCaine Feingold. It makes you wonder if maybe Ralph Nader was right that Democrats and Republicans are the same.

ASIDE 2: The ultrapatriotic — God Bless America — Republican National Committee (as reported by the Business Standard, Jan. 31, 2003) recently out-sourced their fundraising to a company located in India. Exporting American jobs in the midst of exploding unemployment proves conclusively that Democrats and Republicans are not even similar. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Anyone who has compassionate comments may e-mail them to).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 24, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe