By Tom Larmore
(Editor’s note: This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.) When I began this column two months ago, I invited supporters of the city’s Minimum Wage Ordinance to respond so that a dialogue might prove informative to the voters. However, no one has chosen to do so.
Those supporters have now submitted their ballot argument which will appear in the booklet voters will receive later this year. Assuming it reflects the contentions you will be hearing from them over the next few months, it will do as a substitute for a direct response to my points, at least until they submit something to this newspaper. Organizers who support the living wage effort have been asked to provide counter points but have declined to do so for the moment.
Judging from the rhetoric in the ballot argument, supporters of the ordinance would like you to believe it’s all about fancy hotels paying poverty level wages. This complete fabrication is not surprising of course since the law’s proponents have spent the last three years demonizing Santa Monica’s beach hotels as if this were Salem, Mass. in 1692 and the hotels were accused of witchcraft. Although the reasons differ, the strategy is the same. And, of course, the truth is quite different for a variety of reasons, one of which is discussed in this column.
Santa Monica has six high-end hotels: Casa del Mar, Shutters on the Beach, Loews, Le Merigot, the Fairmont Miramar and the recently reopened Viceroy. Employees in the last two are represented by the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union, Local 814; the first four are nonunion, although Local 814 has waged an extensive and unsuccessful organizing campaign at Loews over the last few years.
While the law’s proponents, driven by Local 814, are busy whipping up hysteria over the four non-union hotels, they have failed to mention that those hotels pay wages equivalent to those which the law would require while the two union hotels have not necessarily done so.
For example, compare the wage levels during 2001 at Casa del Mar with those contained in the 2001 union contract for the Viceroy: JOB CATEGORY Housekeeping Supervisor Casa: $12.91 Viceroy: $9.15 Room Attendant Casa: $10.50 Viceroy: $8.15 Houseperson Casa: $10.50 Viceroy: $8.15 Laundry Attendant Casa: $10.50 Viceroy: $8.15 Steward Casa: $10.50 Viceroy: $8.15 Front Desk Agent Casa: $12.38 Viceroy: $10.30 Cook Casa: $12.43 (average) Viceroy: $9.42 Cashier Casa: $10.76 Viceroy: $7.92 Engineer Casa:$10.54 (average) Viceroy: $10.07 Bartender Casa: $10.00 Viceroy: $7.80 Busser Casa: $8.20 Viceroy: $6.75 Server Casa: $6.25 Viceroy: $6.58 Bellman Casa: $6.25 Viceroy: $6.83 (Some of these employees receive a substantial portion of their income from tips that are not counted under the ordinance.) Both Casa del Mar and the Viceroy undoubtedly provide good benefit packages for their employees. However, even if you add the $1.75 the law allows for health benefits and the $1.15 increase the Viceroy contract provided employees for 2002, a total of $2.90, the wages at the Viceroy are still generally below the $12.25 required by the ordinance, particularly for tipped employees.
This is not to say that the Viceroy union contract is a bad one; it may contain other benefits of value to employees. However, non-union employers would not be given credit under the ordinance for higher or additional benefits. But it does demonstrate that an argument in favor of the ordinance consisting of an attack on the four non-union beach hotels is simply spurious and should be viewed as rhetorical nonsense.
So when you see or hear it, recognize it for what it is. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a property rights attorney.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 30, 2002. Read the original PDF.