Skip to content

Agreement flies in face of development etiquette

Published:

By TED WINTERER

Back in November the Macerich Co., owners of the struggling Santa Monica Place mall, unveiled plans to redevelop the site with new retail space, offices, luxury condos and apartments. The design featured three 21-story towers, and the Macerich Web site boasted that the new mall would “create the ultimate decadent shopping experience (for) the affluent to the super-rich.”

Not surprisingly, the public response to Macerich’s plan was largely negative. Folks didn’t like skyscrapers in a beach community that treasures light and views. They didn’t care for the density and traffic from such an intensification of land use. And they didn’t much cotton to a shopping experience touted to rival SoHo and South Beach. Apparently the opportunity to ogle Bentleys and Rolls Royces while stuck in near-gridlock at Fourth and Colorado didn’t thrill many.

Echoing these sentiments, various City Council members decried the proposal, with one going so far as to describe it as “DOA.”

Two months later, Macerich appeared before the City Council with a presentation displaying towers of a height “to be determined after community input.” Macerich asked the City Council to consider a development agreement, an arrangement by which a developer may dodge some of the constraints of our zoning ordinance in return for public benefits.

So what did the City Council do? It voted unanimously to enter into negotiations for a development agreement.

I was shocked. My first thought was that it was a bit like watching a middle-aged Lothario seduce a naive young woman. Then I realized, no, that’s not right: Our City Council members lost their innocence a long time ago.

Instead, the more apt analogy is the way professional sports teams threaten to move if municipalities don’t fund new stadiums that generate additional luxury suite revenues. You see, Macerich is asking that the city, which owns the admittedly ghastly garages at Santa Monica Place, pony up for new underground parking. And no one seems to know what this cost will be, just that it’s extremely expensive.

Basically Macerich told our City Council that if it didn’t negotiate to help build a new stadium, we’d get a minor league team instead of a major league one: A refurbished mall without the pedestrian thoroughfare from the Promenade to Sears and the affordable housing the council covets. Our council looked across the poker table and folded to the bluff.

Yes, the towers won’t be 21 stories. Yes, the council insisted on extensive public input during planning for the new development. Yes, the current mall is an ugly monolith with no curb appeal. But there’s too much about this process that doesn’t pass the sniff test: ■ Macerich asserted that the City Council needed to rush into negotiations because Macy’s and Robinsons-May couldn’t wait, and would renovate their existing clunkers instead of opting for new stores. There’s only one problem: No one from the parent companies of the two stores spoke at the City Council meeting. In a court of law, such testimony would be deemed hearsay and not allowed by a judge. ■ In fact, Federated and May, owners of these two department stores, are in merger talks. According to Sanford C. Bernstein, a prominent market-research firm, chances of the merger being consummated are about 50/50. Wouldn’t it be prudent to wait to see if a reorganized owner of these two stores has different expectations for the site? ■ Macerich now says it considers public opinion vital to its proposed development — but only after it got egg on its face from its initial proposal. If they’re so gung ho on community involvement, where was the outreach to the public during the two years in which they formulated their original plans? Does it trouble anyone to enter negotiations with an outfit that does one thing and then says another? ■ Current zoning for the area adjacent to Santa Monica Place limits building heights to 56 feet. But in an 11th hour move with little public process, City Hall moved the development site into the Civic Center Plan, which allows potentially taller buildings. I’m sorry, but that sort of tactic reminds me too much of Congress trying to add Arctic Refuge drilling to an education spending bill.

Fortunately, nothing’s been agreed to but negotiations. Let’s keep an eye on our City Council. And remind its members that there’s local precedent for saying no. Los Angeles rejected the NFL when the league wanted public monies to finance a new football stadium. Seems like no one’s missed the NFL, just as I imagine no one would miss another Rodeo Drive in downtown Santa Monica. (Ted Winterer is a writer who lives in Ocean Park. He’s quite content to root for the New York Giants from the comfort of his living room. He)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 4, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe