Skip to content

Amazed at assumptions

Published:

By Julia Reeves Santa Monica

In connection with Janet Hand’s, ADA Coordinator, City of Santa Monica, opinion letter (SMDP, June 24) it is interesting to me that the she zeros in on my references in my letter appearing on June 18 to the “down/up ramps on every street corner in Santa Monica.”

My letter related more to the construction of the traffic islands, especially on Wilshire, and to the traffic problems connected therewith. I think I hit upon a sore point regarding the ramps, which was not the central issue of my letter.

However, one reason why I am writing in response to her letter is that today, in less than 30 minutes, I was suddenly accosted by a bicycle rider coming silently from behind me, who blithely glided down the ramp on his bicycle, while shortly after that, I was confronted with a woman who blithely glided up the ramp, riding towards me on the sidewalk — both of whom were in violation of the law and were abusing the reason for which the ramps were constructed in the first place.

Furthermore, I again repeat that I rarely, if ever, see a seriously handicapped person using the ramps and for Ms. Hand to state as she does, that she “can confidently say that many of the people she (meaning me) sees using them have a permanent or temporary disability” is a major assumption on her part.

Unless she resides in the part of my brain reserved for vision, she has not a clue as to what I see. Mothers pushing strollers are perfectly capable of maneuvering up and down curbs. However, I do admit that ramps make their journeys more facile. I did not know that it was legal for “skaters” to skate on sidewalks reserved for pedestrians, thereby endangering pedestrian safety, but, by all means, let’s make their traverses easier.

Regarding Ms. Hand’s statement that “Non-apparent disabilities that limit mobility include arthritis, heart disease, respiratory illness, multiple sclerosis and a host of other conditions” does not mean that any one of these individuals are incapable of raising a foot up or down a curb without causing them harm. As a matter of fact, this minute mobile action might in fact be good for them. With all due respect to individuals suffering from these maladies, I believe it is good for their spirits, as well as their inherent infirmities to shake a leg or two, or climb up or down a curb.

How can anyone assume that I myself, do not have arthritic knees as M. Iles has done in the opinion letter appearing in SMDP of June 20? It is amazing to me how many uninformed assumptions people make. As for the island being havens for those suffering thusly, we'll see!

Lastly, I am enlightened regarding the fact that “curb ramps are required by both state and federal law to allow full physical access to sidewalks for people with physical disability that does not permit them to step up on (or down from) a curb.”

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 28, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe