By GUEST COMMENTARY BY BENNET G. KELLEY
One of the distinguishing features of Arnold Schwarzenegger the politician has been his penchant for seeking sweeping reforms. While his supporters have good reason to push for a Constitutional amendment to remove the “natural born citizen” requirement that would bar a Schwarzenegger Presidential campaign, we would be far better served with an “Arnold style” amendment that redefines how we elect the President of the United States.
The starting point is to address an important Constitutional oversight — our right to vote. In Bush versus Gore, the Supreme Court held that “the individual citizen has no federal Constitutional right to vote for electors for the President of the United States.” Any amendment must guarantee that all qualified citizens have the right to vote in any public election held in their jurisdiction and that right shall not be denied or abridged in any manner.
The next issue is allowing voters to select the best candidate for the job. The “natural born citizen” restriction may have made sense for a newly established republic fearful of European domination, but it does not make sense today for a global superpower that is a nation of immigrants. The fact is that immigrants have long served this nation with honor and distinction at the highest levels of government. Democrats may be reluctant to grant this opportunity for such a popular Republican, but they should do so both because it is the right thing to do and it will create opportunities for Democrats, as well with candidates such as Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm who was born in Canada.
If we truly want to protect our ability to select the best candidate for the job, however, we should repeal the 22nd Amendment which limits presidents to two terms. I am sure there are many Republicans who would love to permit George W. Bush to serve a third term, just as there are Democrats who long to lure Bill Clinton from retirement. It is a sad fact that in 2008, the two most able politicians of their generations will be prohibited from running. There is little doubt that a Bush-Clinton race would generate such enormous voter interest that Congress might even be tempted to have the debates on pay-per-view to reduce the deficit.
We also need to reform how we select a president. Had John Kerry won 1,346 more votes in each Ohio county he would have become the second president in a row to lose the popular vote. President Bush would then have had the befuddling distinction of being the only president to win when he lost and then lose when he won. This is no way to select the leader of the free world. It is time to abolish the Electoral College and allow the people to elect the president.
In 1969, the House of Representatives voted 338-70 for the direct popular election of the president with a runoff between the top two candidates should no candidate obtain 40 percent. This is a good starting point for debate, although the proposal could be updated to permit an instant runoff by having voters also select their second choice, and would enable future presidential elections to be contested nationwide and not just in a handful of states.
The final issue is how we hold elections. The National Commission on Federal Election Reform was right to recommend that Election Day be a holiday, possibly in combination with Veterans’ Day. We also need to ensure voter confidence and fairness in the administration of elections and any amendment should require that Congress set threshold standards for states on voter registration, polling hours, absentee and provisional ballots, recounts, challenge procedures and voting machines.
Another important step would be to de-politicize the election process. We should make Katherine Harris an icon of the past by requiring that elections be administered by state civil servants answerable to a non-partisan commission.
The last two elections have demonstrated that our presidential election system requires reform. A Constitutional amendment merely removing the “natural born citizen” requirement is not the solution, since only an “Arnold-style” approach will allow us to say “hasta la vista” to the current discontent with the election system. (Bennet Kelley is a Santa Monica resident, an attorney and was the cofounder and former national co-chair of the Democratic National Committee’s Saxophone Club).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 29, 2004. Read the original PDF.