Skip to content

and Tailoring exp. 5/31/02 Law needs changing, or spam will continue

Published:

By Reinhard Kargl

Unfortunately your article (“Telemarketer Triumphant in Santa Monica Court,”) by A. Fixmer, May 6, 2002) did not fully explain small claims judge Shcolnek’s reasons for ruling in favor of the telemarketer in this case.

The implied fact that the telemarketer was not actually telemarketing, but only offering a “free financial analysis” does not appear to be relevant in case the tele-marketer used a pre-recorded voice, as the plaintiff claimed.

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act, dating back to 1991, prohibits the use of “artificial or pre-recorded” voices, except in certain cases. It also requires companies to stop calling a number if the called party requests to be placed on a “do-not-call” list.

However, telemarketers are now using various schemes to circumvent the act, and they are fully aware that many of them are operating in gray areas of the law. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act is hopelessly outdated, too cumbersome to enforce, and it has failed to do its intended purpose. It was poorly drafted to begin with, and it certainly did not keep up with progress in computer technology and changes in the telecommunications industry.

Unless we adopt better legislation, our answering machines will soon be bursting with junk messages as much as our e-mail boxes bursting with spam today.

I recently wrote a detailed letter to Congressman Waxman on this issue. Anyone who is interested can read my letter at: http://www.reinhardkargl.com/correspondence/to_waxman.html>, http://www.reinhardkargl.com/correspondence/to_wax-man.html</A>

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 8, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe