By Aldona Meiluyte Santa Monica
With great interest I have read Cliff Nichols’ column “Defense attorneys symbolic of higher powers” (SMDP, July 11, page 5). I was interested in this article because I myself was often asked the same question, “How can you defend criminals?” when I practiced law in the former Soviet Union as a criminal defense attorney. I am ready now to practice law here in California — a few days ago, I took the American attorney’s oath.
Very often criminal defense attorneys are viewed by the general public as persons who using their legal knowledge and skills try to help those accused of committing crimes to evade responsibility, to escape justice. Perhaps many Americans are convinced that O.J. Simpson was guilty and only because of the efforts of his defense “dream team” lawyers he was able to get away with murdering his wife and the wife’s friend. Therefore, if it is understandable that people somehow perplexed pose this question: “How can you defend criminals?” They mean, “How can you help them escape justice?”
Therefore, contrary to Mr. Nichols, I do not find this question indelicate, tactless or improper. I would have been somehow embarrassed if a lawyer had asked me such a question. But when people not well versed in legal matters are surprised that is it possible to defend those whom they consider criminal because they think there is enough evidence to prove their crimes, it seems to me quite natural.
It is hard to understand why Mr. Nichols, an experienced American attorney, assumes that the question is completely out of place and only people with the personal shortcomings may ask such a question. However, in this column, Mr. Nichols addresses this particular question and tries to give it an expansive answer.
Mr. Nichols’ answer seems to me as much confusing as a little of the article. So, disagreeing with Mr. Nichols, I state that the answer could not be so complex. At least I, no matter how much time allocated, always used to give the same simple reply. First, I explained the meaning of the presumption of innocence. Second, even in Russia, I complained the rights of criminal defendants and explained that with the help of an attorney those rights could be better protected, and that there is an attorney’s professional duty to protect the rights of criminals. (Even in the Soviet Union, criminals had some rights.) Mr. Nichols proudly declares that he “does not defend criminals, he defends only those accused of crimes.” But many of those accused of crimes actually did commit crimes and therefore are criminals. We cannot know for sure before the trial whether there is enough evidence to prove that defendants in criminal cases are guilty of the crimes incriminated to them. The very purpose of trial is to learn the truth whether accused persons are really guilty. Because the American legal system is not inquisitorial but adversarial, it is presumed that the best way to find the truth is to allow the two sides — prosecuting and defending — to compete in a public trial before the impartial jury of peers. So, a defense attorney is an indispensable part of a judicial process, and those lawyers who have chosen to work as a defense attorneys have a professional duty to defend criminals (not only wrongfully accused persons). The constitutionally approved due process requires that every person in custody should have the right to have an attorney before being investigated, and every person accused of a crime for which a person may be imprisoned should have the right to have an attorney at trial. Because of the adversarial nature of the criminal procedure and the complexity of American law, very rarely a criminal defendant is allowed to defend himself or herself with no counsel attendant.
Mr. Nichols presents three different criminal cases (he calls those cases scenarios) where young persons have been tried. It is unclear what offenses committed a 12-year-old boy who was accused with two felonies; in scenario two, a young man who seems to be mentally disabled and clearly under the influence of a satanic worshipper mother had desecrated a graveyard; and in the last example — it is hard to believe — a high school student was charged with felony animal abuse for killing a chicken and bringing it to his high school speech class. Mr. Nichols asks: “Which of the clients didn’t need an attorney?”
These three defendants clearly needed legal help, and it seems that in those three presented cases, defense may prove to be very effective. But what about those cases where defense attorneys are unable to convince a jury that the defendant should be acquitted? Does it mean that in those cases clients do not need an attorney? Whether defendant Michael Jackson needed an attorney more than defendant Scott Peterson?
Inconsistently, Mr. Nichols agrees with his colleague’s opinion that all defendants need help: “If they are guilty, they need help, and if they are not guilty, they need help.” Those who are guilty, of course, are criminals, and I am sure that Mr. Nichols defends them.
Two different issues are mixed up here: The effectiveness of counsel’s performance and the problem of the search for the truth. Some defense attorneys accept only those cases that are winnable and then boast they are so smart that they are able to win all cases. I think that a defense attorney like a physician must accept all clients who need help — except when there are some ethical obstacles. We voluntarily have chosen this profession to help people no matter their social status, even their ability to pay, the crimes they committed or the circumstances under which those crimes were committed. An experienced attorney is always able to see the chances of a defendant being acquired. If the prosecution case is very strong, there is plenty of evidence proving the defendant’s guilt — even the best attorney cannot win such a case. There is where the problem arises. People are disgusted and therefore they dislike attorneys when they see that they ignore the truth and by any means, sometimes using laughable arguments, try to convince the jury that their clients should be acquitted. Then people say: “Those attorneys speak for money but not for truth,” and, naturally, despise them.
I have never felt very unhappy when I believed that my client perhaps was guilty and he was convicted. However, there were cases where I thought the client was accused wrongfully and nevertheless the court handed down a guilty verdict. This is a tragedy for an attorney. The first thing you blame yourself: “What kind of an attorney am I that I cannot prove the truth?” No matter that in the Soviet Union there were no jury trials and the judges very often had been bribed. Corrupt judges are the worst problems in Russia and other East European countries. You cannot speak too much of democracy if the main pillar of democracy — the justice system — is completely corrupt.
Sorry, I digressed. Coming back to Mr. Nichols’ column, I must say that the strongest statement Mr. Nichols has made is that he elevates a defense attorney’s job to the mission of Christ. I was shocked by this comparison. Apparently, Mr. Nichols thinks that this is a proper argument to make some who dislike criminal defense attorneys to change their mind. I wonder whether there are a great many American attorneys who share this point of view? Isn’t it clear that only the behavior of attorneys themselves can build their reputation?
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 27, 2005. Read the original PDF.