Skip to content

Answers to the $70,000 question reveal hardly any surprises

Published:

By LEGAL NEWS & VIEWS BY DAVID PISARRA

The City Council’s vaunted consultants have spoken and the $70,000 they were paid has garnered us the taxpayers, the recommendation that we have a picture book for our zoning ordinances.

They made some other recommendations — like field inspectors should be in the field — and if you don’t have enough staff, you should hire more. Duh.

It is precisely this type of thinking that shows the brilliance of the consultants in all their insightful glory. They suggested that meetings be shortened for the Architectural Review Board and the Planning Commission. That sounds very much like the current lawsuit filed by Councilmembers Katz and Holbrook against the city of Santa Monica. The councilmen filed a suit on the basis that late-night City Council meetings violate the state’s open meetings law.

The consultants also suggested that the process be streamlined for administrative approvals. I know how to do that. Let’s take away their responsibility for reviewing the single family homes in R-2 zones. Luckily that one is on the City Council’s agenda for tonight.

The council tonight reviews, again, zoning ordinances. Embedded in this latest version is a provision that will exempt single-family homes in the R-2, R-3, and R-4 zones from having to go through the three-to five-month delay that the ARB adds to a simple addition or remodel.

It is possible that this will actually get passed, as the City Council, in theory, must act before the current interim ordinance expires. But you never know, those wily lawyers might find a way to delay the action once again. It doesn’t really matter that homeowners like me, who are trying to hire an architect, and a general contractor, and a roofer and a plumber and an electrician and a landscape architect, have absolutely no ability to move forward on our projects. No one really cares that the people we would be employing have to wait an additional few months for their paychecks because we are in a holding pattern.

No, the City Council would rather get on its collective soapbox and spout off about the importance of a living wage rather than allow the members of the public to actually pay one. The living wage is a concept that, if I recall correctly, the voters of the city, rejected. Yet the council decided to implement it at a city level, as a show of good faith, rather than actually doing work that will impact their constituents.

I’d rather they show me good faith and allow me to build a home in a timely fashion. I’m not asking for special treatment, or that we abandon all rules and oversight. Just that a simple second story addition to a tiny home which happens to be in an R- 2 zone be approved without having to go to the ARB. It is absurd that an appointed body has the need to review my addition, if in compliance with the applicable codes, just because it can.

It is insane that I cannot even begin design work on my home because no one can give me a definitive answer as to what will be required because the ordinance is either unintelligible or “might change.” People at the building and safety department can’t even explain what the ordinance requires. That’s pathetic and abhorrent to me.

We spend hundreds of thousands of dollars drafting these ordinances and they are unintelligible. I have a degree in mathematics and a law degree. There is a high probability that I am conversant with the English language (though some of my readers might disagree) and I cannot make heads or tails of what is required to build a second story on my house.

Here is why this matters. In economics, a dollar spent is not just a dollar in the economy. If I spend a dollar, it is likely that the person who received that dollar will save 10 cents of it, and spend the other 90 cents. This is in turn done by the people they spend money with. This is called the “Marginal Propensity to Consume” otherwise known as “MPC.” It turns out that when money is spent, it generally creates about 10 times the value of what is spent. That means that if my partner and I spend $200,000 on our second story addition, we have contributed about $2,000,000 to the economy in general, based on the MPC.

This is why allowing us to build in a timely fashion is important. The money that we will spend in this community will help build the community. Money spent goes to families who then spend it on groceries, school activities, taxes and on their homes.

The council has delayed this ordinance with questions about where contractors will park, among other things. According to the staff report, “The Council expressed concern about the recommendation to prohibit the use of nail-on aluminum windows and suggested requiring a two-inch recess where nail-on aluminum windows are used. The proposed language now requires a minimum two-inch off-set from the face of the exterior wall to the window.”

Instead of worrying about “nail-on aluminum windows” the council should get to the heart of the matter, and allow some work to get done.

Enough with the consultants who tell us what we already know. I said months ago I could solve this problem with a carafe of coffee from Peet’s and lunch with local contractors.

Based on the report from Matrix Consulting, I think I could have saved the city about $70,000. They offered nothing new and exciting, and only delayed the project long enough to justify their pay-check. I say enough with the pettifogging legislating, enough with the endless delays and re-routing of ordinances.

These people were elected to get a job done, it’s about damn time they did it and tonight is the perfect opportunity to tell them so. (David Pisarra is a business development lawyer in the Santa Monica firm of Pisarra & Grist. He welcomes your questions and comments. He or (310) 664- 9969).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 13, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe