Skip to content

Are the U.N. inspections working or is it all irrelevant?

Published:

By Paul Corrigan

In late January, there was video out of Iraq of a man who jumped into one of the SUVs the United Nations is using to perform weapon inspections. Over and over again he yelled, “Save me! Save me!” The U.N. inspectors handed him back to Iraqi security forces.

This incident illustrates the choice the United Nations is facing. With the help of France, Germany and the domestic antiwar movement, the United Nations can destroy its own usefulness by abdicating its responsibility to enforce the rule of law. Criticism of the anti-war movement is not the same as accusing them of being unpatriotic. That idea seems be coming solely from a movement intent on deflecting criticism.

The catch phrase of the anti-war movement is “let the inspectors work.” This misses the point of the inspections. If they “work,” one very successful outcome will be the discovery that Saddam Hussein has continued to gather weapons of mass destruction and containment has failed. In fact, the inspections have already worked.

The questions that should be asked is what kind of threat does this pose? Asking what kind of threat this posses solely to the United States seems too reminiscent of the isolationist movement of the 1930s. Saddam’s past offers the start of an answer.

On Aug. 25, 1988, the village of Birjinni in northern Iraq was attacked with nerve gas. Some in the village died quickly. Many more suffered. Today their safety is guaranteed only by constant air patrols enforcing no-fly zones.

A few years later, Iraq invaded Kuwait. It was unprovoked and ruthless. Saddam Hussein looted and raped that country. His surrender was not brought about with inspections and diplomacy, it was brought about by stealth fighters and M-1 tanks. Even the current inspections wouldn’t be happening without the threat from carrier groups in the Mediterranean and Persian Gulf.

Last week, eight European nations pledged their support to military action and support is growing. The recent discovery that Saddam Hussein has missiles with a longer range than previously thought was probably met in Paris and Berlin with the reaction, “Just how long a range are we talking about?... Not long enough, phew... we still believe in containment and America is a bully.” It won’t be long before France and Germany find a way to jump on the bandwagon while claiming they haven’t changed their position at all.

What if France and Germany continue to balk at military action? Well, Amnesty International says that “sacrificing the human rights of people for the sake of geopolitics is unacceptable.” That quote was dated Jan. 26, 2003. That’s 15 years after Saddam Hussein launched a gas attack against his own people, 12 years after he invaded Kuwait and one day after an Iraqi man jumped into an United Nations Land Rover and pleaded for help. It’s time for the U.N. to decide if it is still relevant. (Paul Corrigan is a Santa Monica resident.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 10, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe