How Much Is Enough?
By Connie Dawson
Years ago, while teaching a college class in parenting, I talked about the importance of using responsible language. Jean Illsley Clarke, author of “Self Esteem: A Family Affair,” identified how the use of language can make clear — or unclear — who is responsible for what. Using responsible language can prevent many control battles that end badly. Using irresponsible language can invite a mess and doesn’t address the original request or problem.
A COLLEGE CLASS EXPERIMENT To hear and feel the difference between responsible and irresponsible language, I asked pairs of students to take turns role playing the parent and the child. I asked the parent to say in a kind but firm way, “I need you to pick up your toys now,” to their partners. Then, “Please pick up your toys now.” I heard their responses to both.
I moved on to another class topic but had to stop because of four intensely engaged women in the back of the room. “What’s going on?” I asked. Turns out, they were fussing about having been misled into using the “I need you to” strategy and had it backfire way too often. They were anxious to try something that worked better.
Responsible language avoids conflict Here’s a clue when we’re using irresponsible language. When we hear a request or a directive and could respond with “so?” and a curled upper lip, the language is not clear about who is responsible for what. Try these: 1. “I need you to pick up your toys.” “Please put your toys in the toy box now.” 2. “Please put your shoes on, OK?” “Please put your shoes on now. We’re leaving.” A tip: When issuing a directive, assume it will be carried out and leave the room, or be about your business. If the child fails to comply, she doesn’t get to continue to receive your multitudinous services. She doesn’t help, you don’t help. When she asks or demands something from you, great consideration should be given to her previous non-cooperation. Life is, after all, a two-way street. Reciprocity rules.
There are many, many times in the everyday course of parenting that life goes a lot smoother when the parent is in
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 7, 2004. Read the original PDF.