Skip to content

Assigning a definition to sublease and lease

Published:

By CHRISTINA S. PORTER

Just what exactly is the difference between a sublease and the assignment of a lease?

There is confusion among many in the world of commercial real estate on what the two definitions mean.

For a portion of my commercial real estate career I was under the impression that an assignment is to a lease what a sale is to a building, allowing the tenant, or “assignor,” to effectively relinquish his interest and rid itself of his “obligations,” while a sublease is a lease within a lease providing similar remedies for a default present in a lease agreement with the sublessor, or tenant, maintaining his original obligation at all times and keeping his right to regain possession of the premises. In actuality, when you assign or sublease the tenant is not released from liability, even though both forms of transfer require that the tenant give up possession of the premises, an assignor does not keep its right to regain possession as a sublessor does.

The ability to sublease and/or assignment of a lease is a standard provision when proposing to lease a property and is generally accepted by landlords — with the restriction that it is subject to the landlord’s consent which shall not be unreasonably withheld. This restriction imparts good faith and fair dealing, taking away the landlord’s ability to refuse a proposed assignment or sublease arbitrarily. It is important to know that if there is no provision in a lease for subleasing or assigning stating otherwise, it is assumed that it is allowed. Similarly, if the provision does not stipulate that the landlord cannot “unreasonably withhold” his approval then he may be allowed to withhold it arbitrarily and capriciously. In his fight to maintain control of a property, a landlord may require a “recapture” provision which usually states that at the mere proposal of an assignment or sublease the landlord may terminate the lease. This would be significant when a tenant is paying below market rent and there is a profit to be made by subleasing or assigning the lease.

Assignment and subleasing are necessary for businesses, big and small, to maintain flexibility. On the other hand, landlords find it difficult to allow it if they need to control the type of tenant that occupies their building. This would apply mostly to retail landlords who depend heavily on the tenant mix for the success of their project, or office building owners who depend on the ground floor tenants who could be providing a service to the office tenants like a bank or cafe. (The above information is negotiable and dependent on the market conditions at the time of the negotiation. It is meant for informational purposes only and not meant to be taken as advice. Christina S. Porter is in the business of Leasing and Selling office and industrial buildings, she (310) 806-6104 or).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 30, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe