Skip to content

Attempt to squash public record ‘amusing’

Published:

As an independent journalist at the beginning of his career, I’m quite amused by the possibility that Cyril Viguier may sue you for misrepresentation (SMDP, Feb. 17, page 1). Can someone please explain to me how a report about a bad judgment, even if some minor details are wrong, is more damaging than the existence of the actual verdict?

Obviously, the Surf Channel Limited Liability Corp. exists to insulate Viguier from having to pay in most cases, but the concept of separate corporate entities breaks down in the face of real world business. You can’t shake hands with a company, but you can with the responsible officer of that company. No one disputes Viguier’s status as that officer. No one disputes that he was a named party to a civil fraud case. No one disputes that a jury found both the company and the officer liable for that fraud. Since these facts are public record, available to anyone with the money to pay either the court clerk or the online service, how does Viguier get off complaining about the newspaper that decided to print these facts for its readers?

Because Viguier can’t hide these facts, he will have to take the hit to his reputation, which will happen regardless of the newspapers that print the story. Any sound businessman will check up on potential partners whether or not there are printed stories. Fifty bucks will usually get you a fairly complete picture from an online records search service. The man that walked from Viguier’s deal was not reacting to the minutia of who pays, which is at the core of Viguier’s argument. The guy walked because a company that is too small for the officer to claim ignorance of employee malfeasance got caught using questionable business practices. If this man had been on his game, he wouldn’t have needed the Daily Press to warn him about who he was dealing with. Obviously, people don’t like spending the money for proper records searches.

We read newspapers to learn this information. It is not the fault of the newspaper that people who get caught skirting or breaking the law will have their reputations harmed. That is the same “Prior Restraint” lunacy that the federal government tried on the New York Times in the Pentagon Papers case. I find it both amusing and annoying that people caught like this always lash out at the messenger instead of facing up to the fact that no one can escape bad decisions. Of course, they go for the messenger because the public usually trusts the media to do this job for them and that they don’t realize that they could do it for themselves. What this says about our society is the subject of another rant.

The truly annoying part about this affair is the demand to remove the article from the archive. Even a false article is a valuable historical document. Preventing people from accessing these documents smacks to me like the thought control exercised by totalitarian governments. Stalin airbrushed enemies out of pictures once he’d wiped them out. Not being able to access this article would mean that no one could judge for themselves who was right in this case. It would be an affront to history. The best that Viguier could hope for is a banner explaining the disputed nature of the article plastered at the top. This is how the Washington Post has labeled Janet Cooke’s infamous “Jimmy’s World” article.

I am confident that the Daily Press has acted within the bounds of commonly accepted journalistic practice leading to vindication in court. However, the road will be longer than most people want to take. Journalists like me are hoping you will fight this guy for every yard, because we need to feel that we are protected when we do our jobs correctly.

On the bright side of things, this to my knowledge is the first time in the three-year history of the Daily Press that someone wants to sue you. This validates your effect as a local newspaper, so hire a good media lawyer, make sure your insurance is paid up, keep publishing and take a perverse pride in a legal action that will probably wash out in your favor.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 18, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe