Warning to all Daily Press readers who may find themselves summoned to jury duty at the Santa Monica Courthouse: If you want to avoid a nightmarish experience with the court and its sheriffs, make photocopies of every document you send to the court; post your jury responses by certified mail; record names, dates and times of everyone at court with whom you speak, and save all your files where you can find them at a moment’s notice.
It may be only because I saved copies of my juror summons paperwork from last year because I was willing to loudly and nonviolently speak up in Santa Monica courthouse Jury Assembly Room for my civil rights that I am still a free man following a traumatic episode there equal parts Kafka and Donovan Jackson.
The new “streamlined” jury system is resulting in more people being summoned more often - up to twice a year. And, as my elderly, housebound father has learned, there is no longer any automatic exemption for the handicapped or those over 70 years old. As a result, the courts have implemented both a bewildering, multiple-menu, push-button phone response system that many, such as my father and I, simply don’t understand, and that doesn’t allow for a caller to change an incorrect response to a recorded voice prompt, as well as a deluge of inadequate paperwork apparently so overwhelming that the Santa Monica Court, in my case and perhaps in yours, too, simply loses its files who knows where.
On Friday, July 26, I received an official letter from the court, stating: “Our records indicate that you have failed to Section 209, provides any prospective trial juror who has been summoned for service, and who fails to attend, may be attached and compelled to attend; and...the court may find the prospective juror in contempt of court, punishable by fine, incarceration or both...In order to avoid an order to show cause hearing and imposition of a fine, your immediate attention to this matter is imperative.”
Wow! What a false accusation! What frightening, threatened consequences! Fortunately, I was at once able to locate a photocopy of my completed juror questionnaire from last summer, which had excused me from service because at the time I was the sole caretaker for my housebound, infirm father.
Unable to reach a live, human voice on the phone number supplied by the court’s warning, I hustled down to the Santa Monica Courthouse, where a civilian juror employee decided he could not assist this understandably upset victim of the court’s mistakes and called for the Sheriff’s Office to respond.
At once, I was surrounded by multiple deputies who told me (as Inglewood police told Donovan Jackson) to “calm down.” I’ll calm down, I assured them, as soon as the court corrects its errors and withdraws its threats of prison and fines.
A woman deputy grabbed me by the arm; I shouted loudly for her to take her hands off me. Another deputy snatched my court documents and photocopies away from me; again, I protested.
One deputy had the audacity to ask if I were on medication. (Yes, I replied, one anti-cholesterol pill very night). The increase in juror summonses will surely add to the Santa Monica Court’s mistakes, such as losing the file with my jury service exemption.
Sheriff Lee Baca needs to train his deputies now to understand that “the problem” is not necessarily with the angry and upset person in their presence but in the court system’s deficiencies that made that person angry and upset in the first place.
Thankfully, the whole matter was resolved in a matter of minutes by Lt. Bob Corbett, the friendly and efficient officer on duty at the Sheriff’s Marshall Service Branch - largely because I had my photocopy proof from last year.
Most folks, however, won’t be as willing to make such a forcefully loud and nonvio-lently defensive ruckus in a public place, and aren’t likely to be escorted to Lt. Corbett’s private office.
For those of you, I say: Make copies, mail certified, keep all records at a hand. For the courts: Improve your record keeping, avoid frightening innocent citizens with false accusations and upsetting threats.
For the sheriff’s office: Try to avoid treating understandably angry and upset, innocent citizens as if they were convicted criminals or worse.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 31, 2002. Read the original PDF.