Skip to content

Beam me up, there’s no

Published:

intelligent life at SMC

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY PHIL HENDRICKS & CARL GETTLEMAN

Are the problems at Santa Monica College an inevitable byproduct of collective bargaining or the result of a string of poor management decisions? Consider a quote from the Accrediting Commission for Community Colleges Report on Santa Monica College (page 14): “Campus interviews and documents reviewed confirmed that the college does not have a process to evaluate the effectiveness of the ongoing planning and resource allocation process.”

When a public organization such as Santa Monica College is hit with a financial shortfall, as it was last fiscal year, those in charge have to make critical decisions as to how to balance the budget.

The most important consideration in such a situation is to minimize the loss of students, since the college’s revenue from the state is dependent on student enrollment. Yet the SMC Board of Trustees embarked on a cost reduction strategy that was guaranteed to lose 25 percent of their enrollment base. Now the college must recoup somewhere between 7,000-7,500 students to prevent further erosion of revenues. How did one of the most prestigious community colleges in the world get to this state?

At the time that the current SMC Administration took office, community college districts had been relieved of the financial burden of making contributions to the employees’ retirement system. SMC saved well over $1 million a year from retaining those contributions (from 1995-2002). The SMC administration could have used the savings to build the college’s reserves, but opted to hire administrators and managers, nearly doubling their 1995 numbers by the end of 2002. Currently the average statewide ratio at community colleges is 19 support staff/faculty to one administrator/manager. At SMC it is about 10:1. The lower ratio runs contrary to the best practices of modern management theory, which mandates consolidation of management. This excess management is a taxpayer-supported elite that soaks up $3-4 million per year. And that doesn’t include the cost of cell phone bills, lap-tops, or reimbursable expenses. You can buy a lot of vocational education for that money, a lot of maintenance, a lot of teachers.

Tom Donner, speaking for SMC’s administration, asserts in a recent newspaper article that it is the power and intransigence of the college’s unions that have brought SMC to its knees. Nothing could be further from the truth. When the college was faced with a reduction in funding in fiscal year 2003- 2004, both unions worked diligently to find acceptable cost saving strategies that would retain the existing workforce and minimize enrollment losses. Every major proposal by both unions was rejected. Faculty offered to forego raises to preserve programs. Rejected. The support staff union, CSEA, volunteered to take $2 million in pay cuts over one year. Rejected.

Historically, community colleges lay off administrators and managers at a ratio of 3-4 percent for every 1 percent of support staff laid off when shortfalls occur. SMC never approached that ratio during the crisis. SMC’s administration instead opted to engage in layoffs of staff and faculty, and the killing of vocational education programs.

Support staff at the college has not received a raise in three years. We are below the state average in vacation days, holidays, and employer paid retirement contributions. Our overall salary structure is about 10 percentiles lower than it was relative to our position in the community college system in 1995. The college remains severely understaffed in critical areas. We have repeatedly called for a professional analysis of the college’s organizational structure and for a forensic audit of the college’s finances. SMC’s administration has refused to do either.

A well-managed organization with genuine leadership can weather a financial crisis intact. The experience can even pull people together and strengthen the enterprise. That didn’t happen at Santa Monica College. The propensity of the college’s administration to continue to assign blame to the college’s support staff and faculty indicates that they have not yet fully understood the nature and scope of the problem. The public, who foots the bill for the college, has a right to expect that those who govern educational institutions be capable of learning from experience and of developing, recognizing, and accepting innovative strategies for dealing with future financial downturns. (Phil Hendricks is the president of the California School Employees Association, Chapter 36. Carl Gettleman is president of the Classified Senate at Santa Monica College).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe