By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
(Author's note: This column, which ran last year, is even timelier today. Republicans, joined by a number Democrats, are again pushing (and seem virtually assured of passing) a credit card industry backed bankruptcy bill. The bill will make it much harder for consumers to wipe out credit card debt yet does nothing to curb the unethical and predatory practices of the credit card industry.) There is a gang out there that makes Tony Soprano look like a choir boy. They have often targeted those who are poorest, most desperate and with bad credit. To these unfortunates they loan money at exorbitant rates, then threaten drastic consequences should they fall behind in their payments. No, this isn’t a syndicate of loan sharks. They are … Credit card companies. I was not truly cognizant of the full impact of the credit industry’s shady business practices until I noticed that one of my employees seemed depressed. After a lot of coaxing and several threats, she finally admitted that she had run up about $5,000 in credit card debt and was overwhelmed by her payments. Even though this was a significant amount of debt based on her income, it was still a bit puzzling that she was having such a hard time making the payments. I suggested that she show me her monthly bills and we’d explore her options.
Do you know what’s in your wallet … and has it just chewed off your leg? I have to admit, when I saw those five bills, from three different credit card companies, I was stunned. The lowest annual interest rate was 21.15 percent and Providian, which specializes in riskier customers, topped out at a frightening 27.99 percent. But that was just the appetizer. Her Capitol One card, which had a balance of $832, generated a monthly finance charge of $15.61. Manageable, right? Maybe, but since she had fallen behind in her payments there was also a $29 late fee, or about 3.5 percent a month. But wait, there’s more. She was also over her credit limit so Capitol One tacked on an additional $29 fee; ironic as it was their finance charges and late fees that put her over the limit. This brought the total of monthly fees and charges for that one card to $73.61, or 8.85 percent. With compounding, the annual costs could be well over 100 percent and this doesn’t even take into account the annual membership fees that can be another 10 percent or more of your spending limit. I can almost hear Mayer Lanski sitting up in his grave and saying, “Oy vey, why didn’t we think of this?”
A romantic $50 dinner for two kept on your high interest credit card for five years — $165. A $1,000 weekend in Santa Barbara on your card for three years — $2,048. Bankruptcy protection if creditors have their way — worthless. Bankers and creditors have lavished tremendous amounts of money on politicians to insure passage of a bankruptcy bill that would limit bankruptcy relief and offer it to far fewer individual debtors. This bill is unfair on so many levels, chief among them is that it rewards creditors, but does nothing to limit their aggressive marketing or curtail their ever-riskier behavior. The bill, which seemed a sure thing a few months ago, was prevented from coming to a vote because of opposition from newspapers, unions and consumer groups. But this bill is far from dead and you can expect it to rear its ugly head in the near future.
Course of action: Cut up your credit cards. If you own a home, consider a home equity loan. Interest is about 5 percent and, unlike credit card interest, is usually tax deductible. There also are services that will help you negotiate a payment schedule with the credit card company. Often this can include suspension of late fees and finance charges. You can find these credit councilors on the Internet, but check their fees, or better yet, call Info Line, which provides 24-hour information on human service agencies for Los Angeles County, at (310) 551- 2929. You also can negotiate with the credit card companies yourself. Of course, any of these types of arrangements may negatively impact your credit history, but not nearly as much as a bankruptcy. As for the late and over-the-limit fees, tell your credit card companies that you believe they are unfair and usurious. Threaten to contact your congressional representatives. All three companies reversed my employee’s late and over-the-limit charges, reducing her debt by nearly $700. And remember, it may be everywhere you want to be, but if you can’t afford to pay for it, leave home without it. (Comments or requests for copies of this column can be e-mailed to )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 2, 2005. Read the original PDF.