By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
T here has been a mass conversion among the Jewish population as of late. But the conversion is not to Christianity, but rather to George W. Bush. According to polls, Jewish voters who would likely vote for Bush have increased from 17 percent in 2000 to 30 percent if the election were held today. The increase is related to Bush’s support of Israeli Prime Minister Sharon’s Gaza disengagement plan.
Under the plan, Israel would pull out of Gaza, keep some well-established settlements in the West Bank and deny Palestinians the right of return to Israel. The plan, albeit with certain modifications, offers the best chance to break the stalemate of violence. Until this cycle is ended, there is virtually no chance that either camp will embrace the moderate leadership needed to negotiate peace.
However, supporting a Bush presidency based on this single issue is a little like someone stranded on a life raft drinking sea water. It feels good, then it kills you.
Bush has not been a particularly good friend to the Jews. His has been a faint voice condemning the anti-Jewish rhetoric and violence that that has exploded across the globe. And the entire Bush clan, including the president, has been dogged by persistent charges of anti-Semitism.
The president’s grandfather, Prescot, actively helped finance Hitler. Dubbya’s dad, the former President George H. Bush, was forced to fire several members of his presidential campaign when the press uncovered that they were neo-Nazis and anti-Semites.
Brother Jeb faced charges of anti- Semitism when he refused to fire a staffer who sent e-mails with the following Biblical passage: “… Every spirit that acknowledges that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God, but every spirit that does not acknowledge Jesus is not from God. This is the spirit of the antichrist.”
And in 1994, then Texas Governor George W. Bush displayed his own insensitivity when, according to the Austin American-Statesman, he told reporters that he planned to stop in Israel and tell the Jews they were all going to hell.
Even Bush’s support of Israel is suspect. He initially walked away from the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. In fact, the president showed little interest in Israel until he realized his royal Saudi buddies had become vulnerable and that he needed Israeli intelligence to realize the grand neo-conservative scheme of redefining the entire region through American military might.
Of course the Bush-Israel love-fest may simply be the cynical machinations of political puppet master, Karl Rove. Supporting Sharon’s plan not only attracts Jewish voters, but also offers patronage to the president’s Christian Holy Roller base who believe in a Biblical prophecy that presages the second coming of Christ only after Israel returns to its ancestral lands. These lands include the West Bank, parts of which will be annexed by Sharon’s plan.
However, this Fundamentalist Christian support is not good news for the Jews. The prophecy goes on to predict that all but 180,000 Jews will be slaughtered with the survivors having a choice of becoming Jews for Jesus or suffering the eternal torments of hell.
Even if Jews should not meet this dire fate during a second Bush term, there are other more troubling concerns. The next president will likely appoint two Supreme Court Justices. If it is Bush, we can expect nominees cut from the same Shroud of Turin cloth as Justice Scalia. This would leave a bench heavily weighted toward extremist right wing Christian fundamentalist duck hunters.
The effects of such a bench would be catastrophic for Jews as well as other non- Christians. Progressive social ideals normally embraced by Jews would be struck down. Constitutional protections concerning separation of church and state would be dangerously eroded.
These Jews for Bush might find that they are suddenly out of place in their own country. There would be an explosion of predominantly Christian religious symbols adorning many public buildings and spaces. Prayers in the public schools will again be permitted. And though the court might restrict schools to nondenominational prayers, there is little reason to believe that a bible thumping educator from Kansas, whose burning passion is to bring creationism back to the curriculum, will be able to put away his or her religious fervor and avoid the “J” word just because “one of them Jews” — who are going to hell anyway — have infiltrated their classroom.
More appalling is that, if the courts allow vouchers for religious schools, Jews might find themselves paying taxes to fund the Christian equivalent of extremist anti- Semitic Muslim madrasases. Even the relatively moderate Catholic school my wife attended in Queens taught her that the Jews killed Jesus and were all going to hell.
Certainly Israel’s safety and survival is a key issue for American Jews, as it should be for any compassionate human being. But like Jesus in the wilderness, Jewish voters should beware of surrendering to temptation. Because, while a second coming of Bush might herald the rapture for conservative Christians, it will only bring Armageddon for the rest of us.
FLASHBACK ASIDE: Rush Limbaugh called the torture and sexual humiliation at Abu Graib “frat house pranks” and “nothing you couldn’t see on an episode of Friends or at a Brittany Spears concert,” and House Majority Leader, Tom DeLay, said there was no need for a full-fledged investigation because that would be like saying we need an investigation every time there’s police brutality on the streets. Listening to them was like being transported back to the South in the early ’60s and a bunch of porcine, tobacco-chewing, good ol’ boys were explaining why it was no big deal that a young black man had just been castrated and lynched.
And you know what? It’s just as despicable today as it was back then. (Ed Silverstein is a Jewish freelance writer living in Santa Monica. He has never been bar mitzvahed, however, will accept gifts and comments at).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 9, 2004. Read the original PDF.