Skip to content

Blind faith can only lead followers astray

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

So have you heard about Lawrence Greenfeld? He was the director of the Bureau of Justice Statistics. Operative word being “was.” He recently got demoted and according to the New York Times, it is somewhat fortunate that he did not lose his job altogether. The White House personnel office originally urged his resignation, but in the end, they accepted his right as a 23-year bureaucrat — despite his also being an appointee — to select demotion until he earns his full pension benefits in less than one-year’s time.

Why was he demoted? He did his job. While this may come as a surprise to most citizens, for those who follow bureaucratic agencies, it is not at all shocking. Because you know that doing your job well is not always considered a good thing in politics.

Especially, if your job is to oversee your agency’s gathering and distribution of statistics, then it is very likely that you personally could incur wrath from the political higher-ups, or that you might be asked to change your tune to suit the administration’s message.

Why? Statistics aren’t always positive. And they don’t always align with what the president is attempting to accomplish. Worse, they might even reflect negatively upon the president, his administration, and his political party.

This is true whether you work at the Department of Commerce, and the economic numbers don’t look good, or you’re at the Department of Health & Human Services and the number of out-of-wedlock births increases.

Every president wants to be able to say: “The State of the Union is strong and it continues to get stronger.” They dislike having to admit to things like: “On my watch, crime got worse, the economy slipped into recession, and infant mortality increased.” Hence, that is the reason for the political pressure from every president to change the numbers, or to at least hide the numbers.

In this case, the politicos attempted to intimidate a bureaucrat over how to frame a press release about a new report on racial profiling, showing that though all groups are stopped by police about 9 percent of the time, blacks and Hispanics are treated much differently and much worse from whites when they are stopped. Since the bureaucrat wouldn’t budge on the factual reporting of the statistics, they moved the bureaucrat and nixed the press release on the report.

This is just one more example of the Bush Administration tampering with science and information for their political ends. While I am willing to admit that all administrations engage in some efforts to scuttle unfavorable numbers, this administration has been particularly aggressive about making sure that the negative reports don’t surface and dissonant information is altered (see: http://democrats.reform.house.gov/features/politics_and_science/index.htm).

From my perspective, the worst part about having no Democratic power in Washington is that the efforts put forward by Representative Henry Waxman (D- Calif.) to investigate science and the Bush Administration, and the announced investigation of the Greenfeld demotion by Representative John Conyers (D-Mich.) have gone and will go nowhere. Our system works because of competing interests and with everyone in power being a Republican, there is no opposition voice of any relevance. This means that the public is not being served and the Bush Administration is getting away with their continued distortion and suppression of the facts. Without facts, we are continuing to operate as a blind republic.

Here’s The Thing: Ideological fervor is not enough. Good public policy only comes from understanding the world as it is and this is where science informs all of our lives. Science does not work against religion. And religion — understood as an allegorical and soulful endeavor and not a literal or concrete explanation — does not work against science. Integration of the two domains is possible. The most acclaimed scientists in history were religious men — Einstein and Newton to name just two.

Why is it so difficult for so many to comprehend the possibility that God put the natural laws in place, which science allows us to discover, and which God gave us the free will to learn how to discover? Isn’t it possible that God wants us to learn about his universe, naturally, over time, through trial and error, through experimentation and not through revelation? Why should faith have to be blind to be considered real?

Personally, I think God wants us to learn all about him and his magnificence by engaging deeply with every fact we can find about our world. I just wish the Bush Administration would stop being so scared of the facts. But then, they have a lot to lose by telling it like it is and not how they wish it were. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist and teaches at California State University, Channel Islands. She)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 26, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe