By Ruthann Lehrer Landmarks Commissioner Is Bly a political pawn? Editor:
The news report (June 13) of the Santa Monica City Council meeting about the appeal to add a semi-subterranean garage to a Craftsman bungalow in the Third Street Historic District failed to convey why the Landmarks Commission voted 6-0 to deny the application. The Third Street District is a success story in the city, with restoration, renovation and expansion projects going on in the area — all with applications previously approved by the Landmarks Commission.
Property owners are committed to retain the historic character of this special area, and property values are strong. The historic features of the district that are protected by the historic district regulations concern the architectural character of “contributing” (historic) buildings and the unifying context of the streetscape. Shirley Bly’s proposal unsympathetically altered both the architectural features of her contributing Craftsman bungalow and the hillside slope, retaining wall and steps that create a unifying rhythm of the streetscape. The alteration was not just the addition of a garage door, as your article states, but the excavation of the hillside to construct a semi-subterranean attached garage, a feature found in modern houses and never on Craftsman bungalows. In this period, garages and parking were always in the rear, accessed by a driveway from the street. Instead of a pedestrian environment viewing Craftsman homes perched on the hillside, walkers would find a two-car garage in their face. The Landmarks Commission could not make the statutory findings to approve the proposed alterations as compatible with the architecture of the house and the historic features of the streetscape.
The Landmarks Commission has approved many certificates of appropriateness recently, including the improbable conversion of a multi-family bungalow court to a single-family residence, a major addition to a Craftsman bungalow at 7th and Alta, and numerous applications in the Third Street Historic District. While wishing to respond to the changing needs of property owners, necessary to keep historic properties functioning in contemporary times, the over-riding public purpose of the Landmarks Commission is to safeguard those special places that uniquely convey past time and place for the public’s appreciation, education, and sense of connection to the history of Santa Monica.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 15, 2002. Read the original PDF.