Skip to content

Break commandments, not the Constitution

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

Editor’s note: Ed Silverstein is on vacation. This column originally was published in the Santa Monica Daily Press in September of 2003.

The controversy, in which Justice Roy Moore, a Chief Justice for the Alabama State Court, refused to remove a monument depicting the Ten Commandments from the courthouse, had initially left me torn. I thought, “What’s the big deal?” The Ten Commandments serve as a basis for much of our law. I mean, with the exception of politicians, who can argue with “thou shalt not bear false witness.” (For those of you working for Fox News, The Wall Street Journal editorial page and the Washington Times, that means you can’t keep blaming Clinton for Bush’s mistakes.) And I don’t know anyone who has a problem with the “steal and kill” shalt nots.

But wait a minute, that’s only three, what about the other seven?

There was something about honoring thy mother and father. That’s all well and good, but if God expects me to shell out an extra $20,000 a year so my parents can stay in nursing homes that have no mice and serve hot food, then we’ve got a problem. Another thing — do we really have to send birthday cards to parents that were abusive or incestuous? What about if your father kills your mother, are you still supposed to honor him? And my grandmother wants to know where she fits into all this.

Look, I can live with the parent stuff. And I can even get down with that long one about not coveting thy neighbor’s house (I live in a condo so I’m exempt); thy neighbor’s wife (which is OK, but I reserve the right to change my mind if Michael Douglas moves in next door); thy neighbor’s ass (too easy); thy neighbor’s maidservant (does that include nannies?); and thy neighbor’s ox (who the hell has an ox?). Also, since this passage implies that thy neighbor is a man, I figure anything owned by a woman is fair game, in which case I might covet thy neighbor’s ass. Sorry, I couldn’t resist.

And isn’t it a little redundant for God to ban coveting thy neighbor’s wife when you’ve already been told, “Thou shalt not commit adultery?” Which, by the way, is more bad news for politicians, but surprisingly good news for gays. By the grace of the Pope, George Bush and small-minded people everywhere, gays can’t get married. Hence, technically, they can’t commit adultery. Further, there is nothing in the Commandments (and thanks to the Supreme Court, U.S. law) that prohibits same sex relations. Come to think of it, adultery isn’t even against the law.

But that’s only makes six commandments. What are the other four?

I looked them up. The first commandment is, “Thou shalt have no other Gods before me.” Well, I don’t have any God before him or any God after him. I am agnostic so I really don’t have any God, with the possible exception of Steven Speilberg. Oh jeez, I think I just blew number three, “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain.” And while I’m at it, I might as well confess that I am also guilty of violating commandment four because I’m writing this on the Sabbath. At least I think it’s the Sabbath. It’s Sunday, which technically isn’t my Sabbath, well technically I don’t really have a Sabbath, but if I did it would have been yesterday. Of course, I worked all day yesterday, too, so I’m screwed any way you look at it. Well at least I’m OK with the second commandment that is something about no graven images. Hmm, just to be sure I better rub my lucky rabbit foot.

So let’s review. Through the course of my life I have broken at least seven of the Ten Commandments (and it could be eight if Douglas does move in next door). In fact, I was able to violate the first four commandments in the space of one paragraph. And I did all of this without ruffling the feathers of even a single criminal statute. That’s because the commandments have almost nothing to do with the law — they have to do with religion. What’s more, they don’t even represent the beliefs of the majority of the world’s population.

Now maybe I’m mistaken, but despite the Patriot Act, there is a little document that goes by the name of the Constitution. And I’m pretty sure, unless the Bush Administration has edited out the offending passages, that there is some pretty clear language about the separation of church and state.

So should a monument that has very little to do with the law, that is offensive to any number of people and that spits in the face of the U.S. Constitution be represented in a court of law, or for that matter in any government facility? Absolutely not.

But there is an even more important question. Is any judge who puts God’s law over the law of the land capable of imparting impartial judgment? No. And any judge who thinks otherwise should suffer the same fate as the Alabama Ten Commandment Monument. They should be placed somewhere out of the public view. (Ed Silverstein)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 13, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe