By Todd Flora
Times are tough, and both public and private budgets are tight. As a result, people are not in a very generous mood. Recent polls show that the more tolerant attitudes towards immigrants in the late 1990s have returned to the resentful Prop. 187 levels of 1994. Others ask why a grocery worker should allegedly get what they themselves don’t seemingly have.
Yet most have been misled to believe that grocery workers are haggling over contributing a mere $5 a week to their health plan, when in fact much more is at stake financially, and symbolically. What the grocery workers are fighting for is nothing less than an encroachment on benefits and respect for all of us — from professionals to unskilled laborers.
It has become quite fashionable in recent times to bash working class people and organized labor and blame them for nothing short of California’s private sector meltdown. A recent L.A. Times article proclaimed that an emerging ballot measure aimed at repealing the new law requiring larger employers to pay health benefits beginning in 2006 — known as Senate Bill 2 — was “a blow to organized labor.” Huh? I see it more as a blow to people without health insurance. In fact, organized or not, a surprising number of the uninsured have incomes above $50,000. What’s more, the California Medical Association was also a sponsor of the bill. Is the possibility of repeal a blow to them as well? Why did the Times single out organized labor? This is the era of scapegoating and fervor against the working class that we live in today.
But this evening and in the weeks ahead, we have an opportunity to come together as a community and support working people in a way that should make everyone comfortable. We have an opportunity to do what 25 California cities and 120 around the country have done — pass a living wage for city and city contracted workers.
Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism (SMART) is proposing a living wage of $11.51 — the dollar figure that would keep a family of four off taxpayer-funded public assistance — for the modest number of city employees and workers under contracts with the city of $25,000 or more.
In its budget hearings tonight, the City Council should agree to study the financial impacts of implementing the proposal, pass it, and to incorporate the funds for its implementation in the 2004-05 city budget. We will then join Los Angeles, Pasadena, San Jose, Hayward, Alexandria, Va., and New Haven, Conn., among others, which have decided it’s about time to ensure that their own city workforce is no longer eligible for taxpayer-funded food stamps.
The best news of all? A city worker/contractor living wage is unlikely to adversely strain city coffers. New York’s Brennan Center has recently released a study that overwhelmingly demonstrates that city/contractor living wages around the country have produced sound economic development at a lower-than-expected cost. Living wage cities large and small saw city budgets grow less than a mere one tenth of 1 percent. Clearly, this plan will not present us with a tough choice between living wages and schools, or living wages and other vital services.
This city has seen and heard a lot about living wages in the last four years. This latest proposal is clearly smaller in scope than those we’ve voted on recently, but an important first step that will catch Santa Monica up with other leading cities around the state and country. Most importantly, everyone should be able to embrace this proposal. In fact, the Santa Monica Chamber of Commerce and the big hotels supported a similar proposal in 2000. Friends, let’s build a bridge and unite the community around a city worker/contractor living wage. It’s time. (Todd Flora is a government relations manager and six-year resident of Santa Monica. He is active in Heal the Bay and the Democratic Party. To respond or reach Todd, ).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.