By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
Sen. John Kerry and President George W. Bush squared off in their first debate last Thursday. The subject, foreign policy, was expected to be Bush’s strongest, yet only 15 percent of viewers gave the nervous and defensive President the edge while a whopping 61 percent rated a more presidential Kerry the clear victor. And, for once, the Republican juggernaut has not been able to spin away the President’s poor showing.
The reason is that voters were finally able to see the real John Kerry. In contrast to the President’s tired sound bites and nasty attacks, Kerry provided specific plans to win the war in Iraq and combat terrorism.
While Kerry did admit that in his speech about the $87 billion he made a mistake about how he talked about the war, he asserted that Bush made a mistake by going to war, which Kerry termed “… a colossal failure of judgment.” Otherwise, Kerry has been consistent about Iraq, certainly more so than the President, whose justifications for war seem to change on a weekly basis. Kerry has stated from the beginning that he voted to allow the use of force in order to bring Saddam Hussein to the table, and with the President’s explicit promise that he would go to war only as a last resort.
Instead, the President misled us. He did not exhaust all diplomatic solutions, went to war unnecessarily and used the war to enrich big donors such as Haliburton. Kerry voted against the $87 billion because he no longer trusted the President and because the money was to be distributed without proper checks and balances.
Kerry emerged from the debate as a strong leader who would have done everything in his power to avoid the loss of our soldiers’ lives. And, despite his conviction that this was the wrong war at the wrong time in the wrong place, he, like the President, is unequivocal about the necessity to win this war. Where he and the President differ is how to proceed.
For starters, Kerry would heed the advice of his military experts. Bush, on the other hand, ignored his commanders’ battle plans that called for 350,000 to 400,000 troops, instead, using the lives of American soldiers to test Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld’s disastrous pet theory that fewer troops were required, which allowed the violent insurgency to take hold. Kerry also agrees with our commanders that our armed forces are stretched too thin and plans to add two active duty divisions.
Furthermore, Bush has lost the world’s trust. With the insurrection growing worse, many coalition countries are considering withdrawing their troops and have not made good on financial pledges. Kerry, with renewed credibility and a willingness to share reconstruction, believes he can elicit commitments from our allies for both troops and funding for the effort. Kerry also plans to reach out to moderate Muslims, many who perceive Bush as a Christian crusader, and would also make it clear that America has no long-term designs on Iraq’s oil.
In terms of fighting terrorism, Kerry announced that he will stay focused on hunting down and killing terrorists wherever they are, but believes Bush diverted our attention from that goal by attacking Iraq and by allowing Osama bin Laden to escape at Tora Bora when he “out-sourced” his capture to Afghan troops.
Kerry will implement programs that address our vulnerabilities at home, programs that have been ignored by Bush for the three years since 9/11. Specifically, Kerry will provide additional funds for first responders, putting more police and fireman on the streets, as well as provide money to protect our bridges, tunnels, trains, subways and, especially, our ports. Kerry will implement programs to screen cargo on passenger planes, tighten security in nuclear facilities and require chemical companies to secure their plants, which contain some of the world’s most deadly substances.
Kerry has advocated doubling our special forces to combat terrorism around the world. And, most importantly, Kerry wants to contain all Russian nuclear materials — one of the most likely sources for a terrorist nuclear bomb — within four years, rather than the 13 under Bush’s current budget.
But what may be the most telling moment in the debate was Bush’s response to Kerry’s plans. He wanted to know how we would pay for these programs? The answer is: How can we not? There is no price too high to ensure that our families are safe when they travel; that they will not be left blind, on a respirator or dead from a toxic chemical cloud; or vaporized by a nuclear device smuggled into a port. And, Mr. President, if you think protecting us is expensive, imagine what it will cost if Wall Street goes up in a mushroom cloud because you want your rich friends to keep their tax cut.
What this debate clearly demonstrated is that the President, short of cohesive policies, has had to resort to schoolyard attacks. But when he complains about Kerry’s criticism of Iraqi Prime Minister Allowi’s overly rosy speech to Congress, he is being disingenuous. Because, according to the Washington Post, it was Bush’s own operatives who crafted Allowi’s speech so that it would reflect the President’s pie-in-the-sky assessments of Iraq. Nor does the President have any standing when he charges that Kerry is sending mixed messages when, as Kerry pointed out, the President is telling countries they cannot have nuclear weapons while pursuing a brand new nuclear bunker-busting bomb.
And Bush’s assertion that, with him, you know where you stand, seems a bit out of touch when you consider Iraq has become a quagmire, the Taliban is resurfacing in Afghanistan — which now provides 75 percent of the world’s opium — and bin Laden remains free.
Because, as Kerry stated, “It’s one thing to be certain, but you can be certain and wrong.”
And anyone certain that Kerry is not the better choice for President … is just that. (Comments and requests for copies of this column can be sent to: )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 6, 2004. Read the original PDF.