Skip to content

Bush can’t have his cake and eat it, too

Published:

By John Marciano

My former congressmen in upstate New York, a member of the House progressive caucus who has distinguished himself with a fine voting record on issues of economic justice, the environment, peace, telecommunications, and women’s rights recently shared his views on the U.S.-Iraq war and other matters with his constituents.

The congressman’s criticisms of the Bush Administration’s frightening and reactionary policies are on the mark, as is his stated opposition to the war. But along with some in the anti-war movement who oppose Bush’s illegal, immoral and unconstitutional war upon the Iraqis, he wants to oppose the war and embrace those who carry out its horrific policies. He can’t have it both ways.

He states that “we should be very proud of the men and women of our military who are serving our country overseas. In wartime, we Americans pull together. We support our troops and we all try to do our part to ensure the war’s rapid and successful conclusion.” He goes on to argue that because “we [also] have a responsibility to make our opinions known,” he continues “to oppose the war in Iraq.”

The war against Iraq violates Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution: Congress shall declare war. It was not declared by Congress and its lame resolution last fall cannot serve as a substitute — it cannot delegate this power to the president.

The war violates the U.N. Charter, which was ratified by the Senate and is thus the supreme law of the land. The war violates both national and international law; the representative’s recent vote for the House resolution to support the troops, therefore, puts him on record as endorsing it. Will he vote for the $75 billion war funds that Bush wants from Congress and tell us that he still opposes the war? He holds an untenable position: He cannot embrace the troops and claim to be against the war.

In this illegal and unconstitutional war of aggression, American soldiers are being asked to violate U.S. and international law. Thus, they can legally and morally refuse orders from the Commander in Chief or their superiors. They are obligated to follow U.S. and international convenants, not an almost-elected president and congressional representatives who have broken their constitutional oaths of office.

Anti-war activists face the same dilemma as my former representative: We cannot condemn the slaughter of Iraqis and then call for the support of those who carry out illegal and violent acts. Such a position rests on the principle that American life is more precious and worthy than that of Iraqis. This view cannot be defended on any philosophical or religious ground. The only anti-war “support the troops” position is to have them stop the killing now, today, and bring them home.

In an illegal, unconstitutional and murderous war against an already ravaged people, these are not our troops, this is not our government.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 2, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe