Skip to content

Bush needs to embrace dark side

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

If you’ve been following the storms in the Gulf, you know that there is a monster heading towards Galveston, Tex. Hurricane Rita — a category 5 storm — is expected to make landfall sometime late Friday or early Saturday morning. It’s expected to wreak havoc on towns all along the Texas coast, and if it turns to the right, Louisiana is threatened.

Politicians — eager to show that they learned from the mistakes of Hurricane Katrina — have been more adamant about evacuating people from their homes prior to the storm. Texas Governor Rick Perry has ordered the evacuation of everyone along the coast. Overall, about 1.3 million people have left or are in the process of leaving the region. The mayor of Galveston has worked to secure buses and other means of transportation for the residents of her city, focusing on the elderly, the infirm, and the poor first. Some local officials have even let people bring their pets in crates and the buses have begun to resemble a modern day Noah’s Ark.

The Bush Administration has made certain that FEMA is ready to roll. They have brought water, ice, ready-to-eat meals, and they have coordinated with National Guard troops, so that should a military presence be needed, it will be on hand. President Bush has declared a state of emergency in both Texas and Louisiana, opening the doors to several federal assistance programs. On Wednesday, President Bush said, “We hope and pray that hurricane Rita will not be a devastating storm, but we got to be ready for the worst.”

While it is comforting to know that we can learn from our mistakes, it’s painfully apparent watching this coordinated response at the federal, state, and local level how much more could have been done prior to Hurricane Katrina. In other words, it doesn’t take much imagination to wonder how different it would be now had Bush taken the attitude towards Katrina that he took on Wednesday towards Rita. What if he hadn’t been so focused on his vacation? What if he had been willing to cancel his speech in California?

More generally, what if he had been willing to hear bad news? What if he had been willing to consider that a massive hurricane was heading towards Louisiana and if the “worst-case” models were right, then New Orleans could be under water within 48 hours? While some may say, “well he is doing it now,” the point is, why did he need to have a glaring example of why he should do it, in order to do it?

Time Magazine reported last week that President Bush doesn’t like to hear bad news and that he isolates himself, listening only to those staffers who report good things. While some may believe that this behavior only makes him out-of-touch politically, it is much more dangerous than that. What it means is that he doesn’t accurately assess the potential costs or risks associated with his actions. The administration’s overly optimistic assessment of how the Iraq war would turn out is the most obvious example of the danger of this kind of thinking.

Here’s The Thing: President Bush is dangerous as a leader not because he is slow on the uptake of a situation, though his reaction time is not impressive by any means — whether it was seven minutes on the day of the World Trade Center attacks or 72 hours with hurricane Katrina — but this is not his gravest fault.

President Bush is dangerous as a leader because he always likes to look on the bright side of things, and he doesn’t seem to understand that leaders don’t have that luxury. While their job is to tell the people about the bright side, they must be ruthless with themselves about reality and the worst case scenarios. If they are not, then they unwittingly lead their people into perilous situations and they abuse the trust that has been given to them. Leaders must learn to understand, even relish in the darkness if they hope to protect their people from it and this is something President Bush refuses to do now that he has been “born again.” (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and teaches at California State University, Channel Islands. She)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 23, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe