Skip to content

Bush push for defense: Boon or boondoggle?

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

Authors note: Since I wrote this piece in February 2003 there have been several new developments. The Bush Administration, citing national security concerns, quashed a whistle-blower lawsuit by Nira Schwartz. Schwartz was the scientist who was hired to test the system and who contends that it is fatally flawed and will never work.

To avoid further criticism, the Administration has cloaked the project in secrecy obscuring its budget (over $10 billion annually) eliminating oversight, (there have been numerous allegations of impropriety in awarding contracts) and hiding the system’s effectiveness (inside sources claim that the Pentagon continues to rig the tests). Even in the unlikely event that this system is successful, according to the LA Times, Russia has already developed a missile that would defeat it.

With budget deficits approaching $500 billion, it is more important than ever to spend this money on homeland security and our children’s education rather than wasting it on political pork.

July 4, 2001. I was arguing with my brother-in-law, Donny. It was heated. It always was when it came to politics: he a Rush Limbaugh Republican, me a centrist Democrat. In a way, Ralph Nader was right, we were both the same. We both scared the kids.

We were arguing about missile defense. I felt it was a waste of money and a political payoff to big defense contractors, the money better spent employing out of work Russian scientists, securing our borders against terrorists bringing in a suitcase bomb or a biological agent. Donny thought it was needed to protect against rogue nations that might someday have long-range nuclear capabilities. I couldn’t understand his thinking. He, of all people, should have understood the risks of terrorists having actually been in the World Trade Center tower when it was bombed in 1993.

In December, Bush announced that he intends to deploy a limited Missile Defense system by 2004. The cost for the initial research and deployment will be about $9 billion a year and the cost for the fully implemented system is estimated at upwards of a quarter trillion dollars. That’s if it works.

Many scientists and even some of the joint chief s of staff question whether the system can overcome the technical hurdles of “shooting down a bullet with a bullet.” Only five of eight tests have been successful and those under conditions that are akin to expecting North Korea to call the Pentagon with time and coordinates before launching a missile. When failures started to erode support for the system, Rumsfeld granted the agency overseeing the project unprecedented exclusions from normal weapons development oversight. He essentially eliminated all checks and balances and allowed them to proceed with a high degree of secrecy and nearly a blank check. But even Rumsfeld admits that the proposed system in 2004 will only offer “modest protection.”

Actually, it offers great protection, but not against nuclear missiles. Maura Reynolds of the L.A. Times quotes James Lindsay, of the Brookings Institution, who suggests that the reason the administration wants to rush a questionable missile defense into operation in two years is because, once deployed, it will be very hard for a new administration to eliminate the system. Some critics believe Bush is rushing to deploy so that he can claim he fulfilled his campaign promise when he runs for re-election. Whatever the reason, the question remains whether this system is really needed at present. According to the Times, U.S. intelligence agencies concluded that in the next decade it was more likely the U.S. would be attacked by terrorists with biological, chemical or nuclear weapons than an intercontinental missile.

Despite recent threats from North Korea, it still seems obvious that a good portion of these missile defense funds could be more effectively spent to protect our ports, airways and borders, securing deadly chemicals at industry sites throughout the country, to improve intelligence both abroad and here at home and to employ out of work foreign scientists so they are not engaged by terrorists and rogue nations to develop weapons of mass destruction. While missile defense may have a place in the future, we should proceed cautiously, with reasonable expenditures and proper oversight. We need to ensure that this system works before we start dumping billions into what could easily turn into a bottomless pit.

But I have a more personal reason for being skeptical of this huge expense. On the morning of September 11, our phone rang. My wife and I turned on the television and watched the world change. Donny was in the second tower on the 89th floor. He managed to reach his wife on his cell phone and told her he wouldn’t make it out this time. To tell the kids that he loved them. Donny was a nice, generous man and a great father. We had good times and I miss him.

I often think back to our argument and wonder, had the U.S. allocated just a small portion of those billions squandered on ‘Star Wars’ and other missile defense programs for more immediate threats, would Donny be alive today? (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments may be e-mailed to:)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 16, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe