Skip to content

Bush’s science ignores reason, embraces suffering

Published:

By Ed Silverstein

My grandfather died this past week. Although I will miss him, I do not mourn his passing.

Jack Brill was 96 years old, and in many ways he had been gone for a long time. Macular degeneration had taken his sight, and Alzheimer’s disease had robbed him of his ability to walk, communicate or even remember many of the people he loved.

It was heartbreaking for me to witness such a profound decline. And the sadness I might have felt over his death was tempered by relief that he had finally escaped a body that had become a prison.

I have no illusions that science could have prolonged my grandfather’s life. But there is promise of potentially groundbreak-ing medical treatments that could have made his last several years substantially more productive and happy. And although it is too late for him, there are many other grandfathers that don’t deserve to live out their last few years in such a demeaning and pitiful state.

But that is exactly what is going to happen as long as George Bush resides in the White House.

The Bush Administration, in an unholy covenant with extremist religious groups, has conspired to return science to the Stone Age — in which, of course, they don’t believe.

Bush and his hair-shirt fanatics want to do away with stem-cell research. This leading edge of medical technology offers some of the best hope to alleviate symptoms and cure disabling conditions such as diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, cancer, AIDS, spinal-injury paralysis and Alzheimer’s.

Stem-cell research also offers the possibility of cloning body parts for transplant. This would be a boon for the many desperate souls languishing on waiting lists for transplant organs that never arrive. But that is only the half of it.

My sister-in-law had a heart transplant when she was 24. Although the new heart saved her life, it came at a high price. Every day she takes dozens of pills to suppress her immune system and prevent the rejection of her new heart. This regiment extracts a terrible toll on her other organs, leaves her susceptible to pathogens and causes daily bouts of nausea that nearly incapacitate her. Every six months a tube is shoved through her neck and into her heart for a biopsy.

Yet if the transplanted heart were a clone of her own heart, none of this would be necessary. She would very likely lead a perfectly normal life. But President Bush and his minions find this somehow evil.

Boy George has sentenced millions of people to gruesome fates because he believes a mass of cells, no bigger than a pinhead and created completely in a laboratory, constitutes life.

Even if the president believes this to be true — rather than proclaiming such in order to garner support from the Christian right — it is only an unfounded belief. And it is a belief that is not held by the majority of the world. This is why when the president tried to tack a ban against stem-cell research onto a U.N. resolution banning human cloning, he was defeated.

But even here the President is not consistent. He supports in vitro fertilization. This process usually requires several eggs to be extracted, fertilized and grown into a pre-embryonic stage, which is the same stage from which the stem cells used for research are extracted. When an implanted zygote achieves a pregnancy, the remaining fertilized tissue is destroyed or, according to Bush’s professed beliefs, murdered.

While Bush has no problem “murdering” these babies, our compassionate, conservative president refuses to use these masses of (condemned) cells to save lives and end suffering. Instead he has limited all research to existing stem-cell lines, of which only 10 are viable and those of questionable value.

So it is unlikely that we will see Christopher Reeves walk again. Nor will we see Michael J. Fox entertain us with his comedic wizardry. And some grandson will have to watch his grandfather suffer indignity after indignity as he tragically slips away.

So although I might not mourn the death that ended my grandfather’s suffering, I do mourn the time when scientists could strive for medical breakthroughs without first consulting a bible. I want to go back to a time of reason. Atime when men of science are making the decisions that will affect my health rather than a “C” student checking a poll result. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living under the laws of physics in Santa Monica. Comments may be e-mailed to).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 12, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe