Skip to content

Bush’s tax cut plan is pie in the sky

Published:

By Evelyn Jerome

Bush says he wants to stimulate the economy and that giving big tax breaks to corporations and the wealthy will accomplish that. While I agree, to an extent, that business drives the economy by employing workers, it can only be sustained when goods consumption is increasing. More people making stuff requires more people buying stuff. And consumer confidence is the glue that holds it all together — so any tax cuts should be crafted with this as the top goal.

Call me crazy. Call me demand-side.

But I don’t think all tax cuts are inherently a bad idea. I agree that tax breaks stimulate the economy — just tax breaks for a different sector on the taxpaying spectrum.

I look at it this way: Rich people buy what they want regardless of the economy. It’s middle-income people who buy according to their means (and occasionally beyond). Targeted tax breaks should recognize that this is where the difference can be made in our sluggish economy.

All of the recent fuss has been over dividend tax cuts. Washington is clamoring about tax rates on unearned income. They’re talking about how big of a gift to give the top 5 percent of American taxpayers. Maybe that’s why it’s called a stimulus “package.” They’re deciding what color paper to wrap the gift in.

Instead, they should focus on a stimulus “strategy,” targeting tax breaks towards middle-income and lower-income families, especially those with children.

And they must recognize that spending tax dollars on health care, education and infrastructure (like roads and public transit) will benefit those low-and middle-income families down the road.

It’s absurd that as states and municipalities are swimming in red ink, Washington is determining how NOT to collect $350 billion in tax revenue this year. At the same time, they should be figuring out how to collect the billions in revenue they don’t see when corporate America hides it under its figurative mattress each April.

While I support some sensible tax cuts, I can’t fathom the depth of fiscal irresponsibility on display right now in Congress.

Republicans should realize that voters are smart enough to see that most of us have drawn the short straw with this tax cut plan. If they don’t, Democrats have an excellent opportunity to hone their message, focus on the issues that directly effect middle-class families, like health care, education and taxes, and come up with a winner in 2004. (Evelyn Jerome is the founder and principal of Strategic Communications, a communications consulting firm. She is the past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 20, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe