Skip to content

California depends on illegal immigrants

Published:

By Frances Dean Smith Santa Monica

I can't understand why newspapers over and over again allow letter-writers like Dorothy R. Sterling to say, as she did in her letter to you published in the Saturday, Oct. 12 paper, "illegal means just that - against the law.”

Why would anyone want to grant privileges such as drivers' licenses to people who are here illegally and why would the legislature support this without explaining the very simple answer to these questions?

I know that you know the answer, as do our legislators, even though it seems many would-be legislators do not know it yet, thus confusing the issue even more.

I was born in California in 1922 and throughout my entire eighty years of life the economy of the state of California has depended upon the employment of illegal immigrants. The state of California as we know it could not exist without these illegal workers (and this is true of some other states as well).

The state government is powerless against the interests of the wealthy corporations who provide us (and the world) with our food as well as with other goods we use daily, and who profit as they do by employing illegal immigrants, whom they often cheat and abuse but who — whether cheated and abused — must go home to their own country when their employment is over, and who while here do not have any rights because they are illegal.

Who is to stop this practice? One employer might lose the taste for profiting by criminal behavior, but the only option for such an employer would be to go out of business. To try to stay in business and employ U.S. citizens for these essential but painfully onerous jobs would be financial disaster. U.S. citizens will not do that kind of work for the wages these employers must pay if they are to make the profits they make. The market has its ways.

One legislator every now and then attempts to do something to change the story, but the power of the moneyed corporations far outweighs the power of indignant voters.

The sooner the blinders are taken from our eyes on this issue the sooner something at least half-way sensible might begin to be envisioned; I accuse the press of complicity in keeping the dirty secret.

When a Dorothy Sterling asks in a letter to the editor why we want to protect ourselves from mayhem on the state's highways by requiring anyone, not just citizens, who drive motor vehicles, their own or their employer's, to be licensed, the least you could do as a responsible journalist would be to append an editor's note to the published letter with a brief answer.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 22, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe