By John Logan
The current supermarket dispute involving more than 70,000 employees is obviously of considerable importance. First, it is one of the few large labor disputes of recent years. If employees go out on strike over issues of wages and benefits in the United States, employers are allowed to hire permanent replacements to take their places. The United States is one of the few democratic nations that allows companies to hire permanent replacements for striking employees and the only one in which this extreme tactic has been used with any regularity. As a result of employees’ fear of losing their jobs, large strikes are now rare occurrences in the United States. The number of work stoppages involving 1,000 or more employees has declined from 298 in 1977 to just 19 in 2002, a remarkably small number for a workforce of 137 million people. And, as is the case in the supermarket dispute, an increasing number of work stoppages are defensive strikes — attempts by employees to protect existing wages and benefits.
The second issue at stake in the strike is that the spiraling cost of health benefits and the employers’ effort to pass on that cost to their employees affects most Americans. More than 43 million Americans lack health insurance, including 6 million in California. Millions more are under-insured or live in fear of losing their existing coverage. If the supermarket owners prevail, their employees will have to pay approximately 50 percent more for health benefits, rendering them unaffordable to significant numbers of workers. If these workers are then priced out of their employer-provided health insurance, taxpayers will effectively pick up the tab, as they will be forced to seek medical attention in emergency rooms across the state.
Cooperative collective bargaining between employers and unionized employees — previously the norm in the supermarket industry — has been the largest and most successful antipoverty program in postwar America. It has enabled tens of millions of workers to earn decent wages and health benefits, to send their children to college and to retire with dignity. In the service sector, the United Food and Commercial Workers, Service Employees International Union and Hotel and Restaurant Employees International Union have enabled millions of working-class Americans in the retail, healthcare, janitorial and hospitality sectors to win decent wages, health and pension benefits just like the workers at Ralphs, Albertsons and Vons.
But in recent years, these hard won gains have come under increasing threat. American employers have become more aggressive in their pursuit of the union-free workplace and have attempted to shift the costs of health and pension benefits onto employees. Even in the case of the current supermarket dispute, grocery store employers continue to post enormous profits. Safeway, which owns Vons, generated more than $10 billion in profits last year. Safeway CEO Steven Burd (one of George Bush’s top fundraisers) has called the strike “an investment in our future,” something he understands well — between Sept. 3 and Oct. 14, Burd unloaded 300,000 shares of company stock, “earning” $5.2 million in the process. Corporate managers like Burd have fought vigorously efforts by employees to form unions, and have demanded concessions in wages and — increasingly — in health and pension benefits in contract negotiations. As a result of this sustained assault on the freedom of association, unionization rates have plummeted and millions of Americans stuck at the wrong end of the labor market now work under poverty wages with few benefits.
In the supermarket sector, Wal-Mart exemplifies this “low-road,” non-union strategy. Its 800,000 plus (documented and undocumented) workers earn considerably less in wages and benefits than do unionized retail workers. The owners of Ralphs, Albertsons and Vons insist that they need to redistribute the skyrocketing cost of employee health benefits in order to compete with low-road rivals such as Wal-Mart. But even if Wal-Mart were to move into large metropolitan areas in California, city councils will likely require the world’s largest and most profitable retailer to pay prevailing wage rates for the area — not the poverty wages and substandard benefits it usually provides in other parts of the country.
The supermarket strike is not simply a company/worker dispute. Nor is it only about the future of low-paid work. It affects all of us. The outcome of the dispute and others like it will determine the continued viability of the American middle-class. Without the existence of unionized jobs with decent wages and benefits at large and influential employers such as Ralphs, Albertsons and Vons, we will move inexorably toward a polarized and dysfunctional society of haves and have-nots. If these companies succeed in eviscerating their employees’ health benefits, we will move one step closer to becoming “Wal-Mart Nation.” (John Logan teaches in the industrial relations department at the London School of Economics and Political Science. His publications on labor-management relations have appeared in several leading academic journals in the United States, United Kingdom and Canada. He is currently a visiting research fellow at UCLA. He lives in Santa Monica.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 11, 2003. Read the original PDF.