Skip to content

Careful, the ‘thought police’ might get you

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

On the heels of Sept. 11, 2001, a unified and bipartisan Congress passed the USA Patriot Act. Ever since, libertarians of all partisan stripes have been fighting it, arguing that numerous provisions go too far and erode individual civil liberties. Earlier this week, Attorney General Alberto Gonzales testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee, saying that while he would be willing to alter some of the provisions, it has been an important tool in combating terrorism.

From my perspective, the Patriot Act — and the ensuing debate — has been a textbook case of American government. Congress reacted quickly — not deliberately — to a national crisis. Over time, the initial dissenters became a larger interest group, and now because of some of the checks and balances in the system, a tempering of the first response is more likely than not.

I wish all of our national dialogue were this rational.

In the past few months, Harvard University president Lawrence Summers was given a vote of “no confidence” for suggesting that women may not possess the same innate abilities in math and science as men; University of Colorado professor Ward Churchill’s tenure is under review for arguing in a paper that the 9/11 victims in the World Trade Center were the equivalent of “little Eichmanns;” and masters student Scott McConnell was expelled from LeMoyne College for writing a paper advocating the use of corporal punishment.

On top of this, conservative commentators have been leveled with food: William Kristol was hit with a pie, Ann Coulter artfully dodged a pie aimed at her, and salad dressing was tossed at Pat Buchanan.

What is going on? I thought we believed in freedom of speech?

Neither the stupidity of the argument, nor the ignorance of the person, is supposed to matter. Period. If any one of the above individuals were in my class, I’m not certain they would earn a passing grade because their analytical abilities seem to be seriously in question, but they would certainly enjoy the right to make their arguments.

The Supreme Court made it perfectly clear in Texas vs. Johnson (1989): “If there is a bedrock principle underlying the First Amendment, it is that the government may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable.”

But maybe this is the problem. It’s not the government we have to worry about. It’s the people. The politically correct thought police — on both the left and the right.

As my friend, John, said, “It isn’t that you can’t speak, it’s that there are consequences for what you say.”

That terrified me. And while maybe it’s always been true, it seems like it’s gotten worse as our technology has gotten better — as though the ability to monitor speech and to persecute someone with their own poorly chosen words or ill-defined thoughts are inversely related.

I don’t want to live in a country where we all say the same things because everyone has stopped thinking out of fear of repercussion.

And who exactly are all of these people who have decided that they possess such infinite wisdom that they should have the power to dismiss academics and/or engage in physical violence?

Some are pundits, some are students, and some are other academics. All of which scares me more because it seems that now, even those who are educated have lost the ability to think.

Here’s The Thing: Stop worrying about government power, and start worrying about group think. If you want to know who the “they” are, then I’ll let you in on a secret. “They” are not the government. “They” are the marketing people.

“They” are all the people who tell you how to feel about yourself (bad), about the world (not good), and about others (worse relative to), so that you buy more of their products. They have become so incredibly powerful over the past 60 years (since the adoption of television) that it seems that nearly everyone in this society has forgotten how to actually think. Even people who believe themselves rebels are often just spewing off packaged rebellion rhetoric designed to induce a contribution.

Probably the best thing you can do for yourself, if you can’t stop watching television, is watch Bill Maher — the most thinking person on television whose show on ABC got canceled because he dared to utter a controversial thought. Aside from that, read. It does a brain good. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester at California State University, Channel Islands. She)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 8, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe