Skip to content

Charitable giving by force — bah humbug

Published:

By ANY DAY IN LA BY HEIDI MANTEUFFEL

’Tis the season to do a lot of things, but one of them just pisses me off. You’re driving home after a draining day of work, and dangit, you remember that carton of milk you need. So you drag yourself to the grocery store — dragging because the guilty bell and drum girl wait for you vigilantly in the parking lot.

Yes, I know I’m probably one of the few who get frustrated by charitable giving. But the whole thing about charity is that it comes from people choosing to give, and it doesn’t feel like a choice when you get puppy-dog stared every time you go to Von’s for milk.

Here’s the scenario: Tired worker locks her car and heads briskly to the entrance of Pavilions. Only the door is blockaded by some man with a can. He smiles and wishes you a Merry Christmakwanzakka. Once you pass, his smile drops to a frown of disappointment, and he wishes you a blessing in spite of yourself.

You might think I’m kidding, but I’m not. Yesterday a girl literally stopped ringing her bell whenever someone passed and didn’t donate. Every single time.

One of those times I just wanted to say, “Listen, it has nothing to do with you. The fact that I’m worn out from people asking for one more report or 30-minute call to Noenglishstan for tech support is not your problem. I just at this very moment have nothing to give to you.”

But I don’t think she got it. Some feel like an insistent Jewish grandparent to me who measures your love for them by the number of weekly visits. Why don’t you call?

Because I don’t even know you! It’s a Pavlovian response to me. I don’t give you money. Disappointed. I do give you money. You like me, you really do. Listen, I don’t like or not like you, I merely want to choose when and where I give my charity. Is that crazy?

Maybe it is. But it honestly feels like most volunteers are hurt if I don’t give a dollar right then and there. I will give a dollar, but I don’t need someone deciding that now is the time, because no, now is the time to get Pillsbury cookie dough and watch two hours of Ben Stiller in “Dodgeball.”

I’m not saying that charities shouldn’t be able to solicit in front of grocery stores. I know it’s a great source of income for many of them, especially around the holidays. And I feel like a lot of them are for commendable causes. I just wish they weren’t so second grade about it. Stop acting like you didn’t get picked for the team every time someone has a busy day. You can play dodgeball tomorrow.

So yes, I am one of those mean people that doesn’t want to deal with the bells and that shaking can every time I need more lunch meat. It’s partially out of sensed guilt and partially from the guilt I instill in myself. But I like to choose when and where I give my Christmas spirit and not feel like “A Christmas Carol” will start the moment I step into my car. Back off the clutch, Jacob Marley. I am giving this holiday season. Just on my own time without the bells and dodgeball. (Despite her Scrooge demeanor, Heidi is all about Christmas. Let her know what you like or dislike about the holidays by e-mailing her at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe