By LEGAL NEWS & VIEWS BY DAVID PISARRA
What interesting times we live in. Mary Kay Letorneau, the grammar school teacher who had sex with one of her students, a boy of 12, was released on Aug. 4 and on Aug. 7 was allowed to have full contact with her victim. On Aug. 12, the New Jersey Governor announced that he is a “gay American” and resigned his position, the same day that the California Supreme Court says that San Francisco Gavin Newsom overstepped his authority and invalidated 4,000 same-sex relationships. The society we live in will allow Letourneau, the child abuser who spent 7 1/2 years in prison for her crimes, the right to marry.
But Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon, two consenting females, who have been an item for 50 years, are denied the right to marry.
Mary Kay Letourneau is a woman who had a sexual relationship with a 12-year-old boy. She was caught not once, but twice having sex with the underage boy.
She gave birth to two of his children. They are allowed to marry.
Her crimes are so detestable in the eyes of society that she will have to register as a sex offender. Yet she is allowed to marry her victim, simply because he is of the opposite sex than her.
As a culture, we say that pedophilia is so abhorrent that we can isolate you in prison for years. We have so much disgust for the perpetrators, and so much fear of them, that we have Megan’s Law, a law specifically designed to allow us to know which of our neighbors are sexual predators. Yet we allow them the right to marry. We allow prisoners, who are still in prison, the right to marry. But not homosexuals.
In law, we occasionally draw what are called bright line rules. They are the few areas in the law that are not open to interpretation. If you drive and have a blood alcohol level over.08 percent you are automatically considered impaired. If you are 37 and have sex with a 12-year-old it is statutory rape, and there is no defense. There may be a marriage in the end, but the fact is you have violated the law.
Human relationships being what they are, and teenagers being as hormonally active as they are, the law makes allowances for those within certain ages. If a 19-year-old boy has sex with a 17-year-old girl, (or vice versa) technically it is a misdemeanor under California Penal Code Section 261.5, but good luck finding a district attorney who wants to prosecute that case.
In Letourneau’s case, she was 34 and the victim was 12. The age gap is shocking, mostly because of the youth of both parties. If she was 64 and he was 42, it might seem odd enough to raise a few eyebrows, but no one would say there wasn’t consent.
This really is a cultural issue. For throughout the world, the age of consent is varied. In England for example, the age of consent is 16 and in Canada it is currently 14.
But that is only part of the story. The other part is that as a society we are so homophobic that we will deny the right to marry to couples who have been loyal, dedicated, faithful to each other, and for 50 years have been together. When Del Martin and Phyllis Lyon made history in February they were acknowledging their relationship of five decades.
What the California Supreme Court did on Aug. 12 was to slap every gay person in the face and say, “You, you are not good enough to be in our society. You are so vile, so hated, that you are beneath even the child molesters and the murderers.”
It is that type of institutional contempt that caused Gov. Jim McGreevey to step down this past week. Partly because of a brewing scandal about alleged sexual harassment, and partly because of his coming out. Is it any wonder why, for decades now McGreevey has led an outwardly heterosexual life. His two wives, his child and ostensibly the electorate of the state of New Jersey all thought he was a happily married man. In a society that says it is better to be a child molester than a gay person, is it any wonder why he would deceive so many?
The far right Christian fundamentalists are screaming with all their might that the homosexual lobby is trying to destroy the institution of marriage. But since it is an institution that seems to have no qualifications beyond gender, they even let murderers and child molesters in, I don’t think it is the homosexuals who are destroying it.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 17, 2004. Read the original PDF.