Skip to content

City dwelling will either deaden or liven the spirit

Published:

By Caroline Bodkin

I visited my brother and his wife, Gretchen, in San Francisco over the weekend. They live in a small single in an area that cannot be considered the greatest neighborhood. It’s not newlywed ideal, but these newlyweds are just idealistic and energetic enough to be happy there. It’s where they work, live, love.

They are artists, educated — my brother is a writer and philosopher, my sisterin-law is a painter, drawer — and their home is a nest of creativity, complete with all the chaos and clutter of creation. Everything inside the apartment is either made by them (oil paintings, mobiles, poems), is used for making (brushes, pots, paper, books), or is for play (games, cards, tape recorder).

They bake their own bread, make their own yogurt, knit their own scarves, find their furniture, hem their pants, hang-dry their clothing. They own a television that gets no reception but screens the few DVDs they’ve carefully selected to own: “Winged Migration,” “Twin Peaks” (season one,) “Spirited Away.”

They do not waste, they do not want, and they are masters at entertaining themselves.

When I go there I find myself moving between two strong and conflicting sets of emotions toward my brother: I am proud of, admiring of, joyful for him. And I am sad for, protective of, anxious for him.

Because the world around them seems so dissimilar to, so disinterested in the world they’ve created for themselves.

Although my brother’s home life is alive, his daytimes are spent at a bank, where he’s worked for the past couple years to help Gretchen get her MFA as an illustrator. This place makes him miserable, though he’d only ever say that he looks forward to leaving after she graduates in May.

What he will do then, what she will do then, I don’t know. And if they know, or even have an idea, they don’t say so.

While waiting for fresh bread to bake, my brother and I started talking about this summer, their San Francisco end date, and what they might do then. Among other things, he’s considering moving to Los Angeles. So he asked me about the city’s theater life, the writers who work here, the communities that surround them or, better, support them.

I froze. I don’t want to see them living in another small studio apartment (before San Francisco, it was NYC for three years). I want them to have space, a garden, a whole room for painting.

Their apartment is home to two creative and loving people. It is a bubble and seems totally separate from the harsh street and city that surround it. It is the opposite of a bank. My brother lives opposite himself in this way. Inside and outside seem opposite. I want people in the outside world to know how special my brother is — to know what’s going on inside.

I paused before I responded. “Move to New Mexico!” I thought. “Or central Oregon! Learn to build straw-bail houses! Don’t hole yourself up again sucking smog, watching rich people valet park.” It’s a survival instinct, I guess, that we have for our siblings — we want our genetic kin to succeed.

I just want those I love to be happy. Los Angeles. I felt that first set of emotions kick in: sadness, protection, caution. I wanted to protect him from another stretch of years in a city — especially Los Angeles, which even I’ve seen slowly deaden idealistic, creative people like my brother. So I answered his inquiry by first talking about the traffic, then the rent prices, the industry... I so wanted him to stop living opposite himself. I suggested the rural destination. Somewhere he could write or even think, I suggested something of a break...

And then I stopped. The other set of emotions kicked in. The envy and the admiration, the pride and the awe I have for him took over. I could think of nothing but the way he’s proven he can live his chosen life anywhere. I marveled again, briefly, at the integrity with which he does that. Maybe he’s not suffering inside the cities, maybe he’s beaten them.

I told him, you’ll be fine wherever you go. I see it. You’ll be more than fine. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wonders daily if she’ll miss her calling. You can ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 8, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe