By Tom Larmore Santa Monica
The city has recently begun implementing a program requiring building owners who received conditional use or other discretionary permits to submit to an inspection by code compliance officers to determine if all conditions set forth in the permit have been satisfied. While there is nothing untoward about enforcing compliance with applicable zoning and building codes, this procedure has two distinct problems.
First, there are at least two United States Supreme Court cases holding that a municipality cannot force a building owner to permit an inspection unless there is some emergency, or the inspector has obtained a warrant permitting the search. Because this program involves routine inspections without special cause, issuance of a warrant would seem unlikely and the owner should be fully justified in refusing to permit the search.
Second, the notion that an owner should be required to pay for the search is remarkable, particularly if the original permit did not impose such a requirement. Imagine, if you will, being arrested and, while being handcuffed, being handed a bill by the officer to compensate the city for the officer’s time and trouble, whether or not you are ultimately convicted. It’s one thing for the city to impose a fee for a service, such as issuance of a conditional use or building permit. It is quite another to bill for an inspection designed to determine whether the owner has violated the law — and requiring payment even if no violation is found.
The city really ought to rethink this program. The notion that this is a “fee for service” system is ludicrous. Instead, it’s nothing more than a creative source of free money that could easily be extended.
Why not have the hedge police send bills to homeowners whose hedges and fences are inspected, whether or not violations were found? After all, by having a hedge or a fence, they required compliance officers to expend their precious time measuring them. (And, by the way, let’s force the owners to allow the inspectors to have access to their backyards — what’s a little thing like the Fourth Amendment in a progressive city like ours?) Let’s have the low-flow police inspect recently remodeled homes to make sure they have complying toilets and shower heads and then bill the homeowners, even if they do. Whee!
Of course, no one would suggest doing any such thing. However, the current program is equivalent from the perspective of a building owner, and it is no fairer there than it would be in the residential context.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 24, 2004. Read the original PDF.