By James Mount Santa Monica
Most of us in my profession think that the city of Santa Monica has done a poor job of plotting its future by drafting a badly flawed zoning ordinance. It more resembles swiss cheese in that the holes represent the interests that have been left out. It was put together in answer to the shrill cries of a political constituency flexing its muscle without a broad view of the needs of all the community. The original concept remains “if you don’t vote here, you have no say in the future of your land.”
As well intended as the document is, many of the flaws have never been addressed. One of its most egregious features is the concept that if a use is not a permitted use, it cannot be allowed, even by variance or conditional use permit. The wording is: “Other uses determined by the zoning administrator to be similar to those listed above and not more disruptive or disturbing than permitted uses.” There is a term used by other planning departments which allows consideration of unlisted uses. That is “special circumstances.” But here in Santa Monica, the inevitable answer is, “You can’t do that.”
The ever-changing ordinances we have been subjected to make it very difficult for property owners to know what they can do with their property a few years in the future when they are able to improve it. Within reason, there should be a way to allow an owner of some years standing, to utilize the ordinance as it was when they bought the property. This is especially true in the R-1 district because many have anticipated the use of the property they bought when they were younger and improvement was just a dream.
Tonight the City Council will consider extending an emergency ordinance for another 18 months because the planning department has failed to fulfill its promise of a two year turn around. The City Council should refuse to renew the ordinance unless they allow for those who have anticipated building or adding to their property by allowing them to use the ordinance as it stood before this emergency amendment was passed a year ago. This is the time to acknowledge special circumstances, such as proof that the owner had prepared plans before the ordinance was heard or had lived on the site for five years.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 22, 2005. Read the original PDF.