By TED WINTERER
The five or six avid readers of this column (and yes, Mom, I’m counting you) will recall that in my last opus I sounded off about Santa Monica’s Sustainable City Plan and the ways in which our government could do more to promote the goals of this plan. Apparently I’m not done with this rant.
Consider if you will the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) standards for green design. LEED is a voluntary third party certification system for new and renovated buildings. Credits are awarded for various features promoting sustainability and a structure is then rated as Certified, Silver, Gold or Platinum.
Much to its credit, our City Council decided in 2001 that all new municipal construction should meet the LEED Silver benchmark. Thus, the new Public Safety Building employs a variety of resource conservation schemes and the new parking structure at the Civic Center will feature an array of solar panels to provide its energy. So if City Hall continues to suffer from the edifice complex behind its seemingly endless construction binge — which my mother can tell you I believe is ill-advised — at least the impact of these new buildings will be reduced.
But there’s a wrinkle here. While Santa Monica was one of the earliest cities to impose the LEED Silver standards upon itself, Vancouver is now the first to require that its new buildings attain Gold status. Now that the bar’s been raised, shouldn’t we aspire to the same goals of sustainability as our neighbor to the north?
And what about private construction? What can be done to advance green design? Again, Santa Monica has been visionary and in 2001 put into effect the "Green Building Ordinance," which requires energy and water conservation measures and the use of recycled materials. City Hall also developed "Green Building Design" and "Construction Guidelines," which encourage but do not require additional sustainable practices.
But once again, our government could take further steps to foster environmentally sensitive structures. There’s talk of fast-tracking permits for LEED-registered commercial and multi-family projects. LEED for single family residences won’t be available for another year or two. Expedited permits are a nifty idea, one I hope the City Council adopts later this year. But why not offer greater incentives for green design, such as reduced fees for permits on a sliding scale, so that attaining successively higher LEED ratings yield a corresponding reduction in the cost of approvals? Or what about bonus densities so a sustainable building, just like an affordable housing project, can exceed the height and mass limits of the zoning ordinance?
And when LEED standards are introduced for single-family homes, they likewise ought to be used to promote green design. Since owners of individual residences are more likely than developers of larger projects to be deterred by the capital investment required by some aspects of resource-conserving construction, why not waive all permit fees for single family homes which meet certain green criteria? After all, City Hall currently waives fees for renovations of landmarked structures. Aren’t environmentally sensitive buildings equally important?
And as our "Land Use Element" — which governs development in Santa Monica — is revised in the next couple of years, our leaders would do well to incorporate the goals of their own Sustainable City Plan. For instance, the most current report on the progress of the plan acknowledges: “Since 1995, energy use, water use and waste generation have been increasing, largely as a result of new office construction and larger daytime populations resulting from higher occupancy rates in hotels and office buildings.” Sounds to me like we don’t need any more office complexes or hotels.
Finally, City Hall could do more to promote adaptive reuse of existing structures, which is the most sustainable way to redevelop a property. For instance, our current land use policies make it easier and cheaper to scrape an old building in a multi-family district and build condos then to renovate it and add housing. It ought to be the other way around.
But first City Hall would have to disavow its penchant for demolishing and rebuilding. Why would I consider a green-designed reuse of my own home when our government plans to demolish instead of refurbish the RAND Corp.'s old “Z” building, by far the most architecturally and historically compelling structure on the southern stretch of Ocean Avenue? It’s sort of like telling the indigenous people in rain forests they’re better off harvesting nuts than felling trees and then heading home to gorge on Big Macs while driving a SUV. (Ted Winterer is a writer who lives in Ocean Park. He)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 4, 2005. Read the original PDF.