By TED WINTERER
Santa Monica last fall celebrated the 10-year anniversary of its “Sustainable City Plan,” a set of policies promoting sustainability in our community.
Just what is sustainability? It’s a nebulous concept that defies easy definition. The city’s Web site states only a guiding principle: To “meet current lifestyle needs without compromising the ability of future generations to do the same.”
I’m reminded of the 1964 Supreme Court’s struggle to describe obscenity and Justice Potter Stewart’s subjective standard: “I know it when I see it.” And I guess I have my own gut sense of what constitutes sustainability.
Our city is recognized nationally for its pioneering efforts to promote sustainabili-ty and rightly so. We do quite a bit very well for the sake of future Santa Monicans. Still, we fall short in many ways. For instance, the new fire station at Hollister Avenue and Second Street has such intense air conditioning that burly fire men open windows in the summer to bring in warm air: My gut says that’s not sustainable. And the gardens where I live generate more than 100 gallons of clippings and prunings per week, all trucked to a landfill because City Hall won’t allow multi-family residences to recycle yard waste.
There are more significant ways in which City Hall seems to ignore its own Sustainable City Plan. One goal is reducing traffic congestion. Does anyone think the development policies of the last decade have reduced the number of intersections with unacceptable service levels? Another aim of the plan is a balance between jobs and housing in Santa Monica, as much of our traffic derives from too many workers and not enough beds. So why are more office buildings being erected all over town?
Then there’s the first objective listed in the plan: Resource conservation. The mantra of conservation is to first reduce consumption, then reuse goods and finally recycle a product. Thus, it’s no accident that the National Resources Defense Council, a leading environmental advocacy group, chose to remodel an old building for their new headquarters in downtown Santa Monica. The result was that the consumption of new resources was reduced and an older resource was reused.
Likewise, a seminar last fall at the Green Building Resource Center, partly funded by City Hall, emphasized that the most sustainable approach to green building is to refurbish rather than tear down a structure.
So what really sticks in my craw is City Hall’s insistence on demolishing buildings to build newer and bigger ones, instead of reducing its demand for more space and reusing the buildings it owns. The old Main Library is gone, soon to be replaced by a new one. The Big Blue Bus building, a mere 15 years old, will be torn down for a larger structure. There’s talk of razing the City Hall annex and erecting a new city services building. And soon Rand Corp.’s old headquarters will be leveled when it could have been a component of a more artful reworking of our Civic Center.
Yes, all these new structures will be marvels of energy efficiency and resource conservation. But it will take a lot of fluorescent fixtures and double-flush toilets to make up for the environmental impact of this new construction.
Suppose you want to reduce pollution and conserve fuel, so you’re thinking about buying a hybrid to replace the vehicle you bought in 2000. As the average car’s life span is over a dozen years, you’d actually reduce your consumption of the resources used to make cars if you held onto your old ride a bit longer. And it’ll take quite a few years of driving a hybrid to offset the pollution and energy that built it.
Now, imagine I invented a way to install a hybrid engine in the car you own today (and imagine with my new riches I then bought this paper and ran my column on the front page). It might cost you more to retrofit your car than to buy a new hybrid, but for the extra money you’d conserve the resources that go into a new chassis, body, windows, seats, etc.
So far no one seems to be offering hybrid retrofits for cars (and for now “Our Town” will stay in the middle of this paper where it belongs). But certainly one can adaptively reuse old buildings and retrofit them to green building standards. It’s the approach that least compromises future generations, even if it costs more.
But it’s not City Hall’s approach. Maybe the folks in charge want to drive a sexy late-model Prius that makes a self-congratulatory statement rather than a retrofit that looks like just another Taurus. (Ted Winterer is a writer and lives in Ocean Park. He)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 18, 2005. Read the original PDF.