By INCITES By Ed Silverstein
The fabric is composed of cotton, nylon or polyester, approximately 250 threads per square inch, about the same as a standard sheet. It is cut into a rectangle with a length/width ratio of 1.9 to 1. The threads are off white, old-glory red and old-glory blue. And if you set it on fire, you just might go to jail.
That is if Wesley Clark has anything to say about it. The Democratic candidate for president recently announced his support for a constitutional amendment that makes it a crime to burn or desecrate the flag. His view is shared by many in the government, including, at one time, progressive Congressman and presidential wishful-thinker Dennis Kucinich, who voted for the amendment, though he has since changed his position.
Regardless of the support, any amendment banning flag burning would be wrong.
Making a piece of cloth, or any symbol for that matter, into a sacred cow is positively un-American.
It is the type of law one would expect from despotic dictators, such as Saddam Hussein, or countries that are without civil liberties, such as China, where, ironically, most American flags are now made.
It is doubtful that those who fled to America to escape persecution for their beliefs would sanction such an action. Nor is it likely that the framers of the Constitution, who had burned their share of British flags in protest, would ever agree to such a provision. And of course banning flag burning is unconstitutional, which is the very reason it needs to be an amendment.
But the truth is that the flag burning amendment isn’t really about elevating a piece of foreign-manufactured cloth to the status of a graven image.
Like gay rights and the ban on late-term abortions, the flag burning amendment is a Republican dirty trick. It was designed to force Democrats to choose between what is emotionally popular with crucial swing voters and what is morally right, such as defending civil liberties and constitutionally guaranteed free speech.
The Republicans are hoping that Democrats will oppose the anti-flag-burning amendment so they can brand them as unpatriotic during the next election.
That is not to say that Republicans don’t believe in free speech. They will fight to the death protecting the rights of corporations and special interest groups to contribute massive amounts of cash to get Republicans elected. But I digress.
Our country was built on liberty and freedom. Many people feel proud to be an American and want to celebrate that pride through a symbol of our country. And I support their right to fly the flag, display it in their windows, sew it onto their jackets, paste it onto their Harleys, hang it from car antennas or wave it at a parade.
But there are those who are disappointed by our country. Some have been treated unfairly or are distressed by the support and participation of the United States in actions and policies that are immoral and illegal. And they too should have the right to use the flag to express their feelings.
It is difficult to endorse any presidential candidate who would support an amendment that would have allowed the arrest of students who burned flags to protest millions of senseless deaths in Vietnam. And I am disappointed that Wesley Clark would countenance a law that could very well imprison unemployed American textile workers for burning the very Chinese-made flag that took away their jobs.
When burning a symbol of our country’s freedom can result in the loss of a person’s freedom, then the country is no longer free, and the symbol is worthless.
Thus any amendment that bans flag burning robs the flag of everything worth protecting.
As for General Clark, this is one position that he might want to rethink.
NOTE: Flag specifications were provided by www.gettysburgflag.com, where flags are still manufactured in America. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. He will flag all comments sent to).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 19, 2003. Read the original PDF.