Skip to content

Carole Orlin: Doors open on oil dependence and the hydrogen highway

Published:

SCENTS The hydrogen highway might be leading us to a dead end

By CAROLE ORLIN

Since my last column appeared in the SMDP two weeks ago (“Bush-wacked on the road to the hydrogen highway”), more doors continue to open. In that column, I focused on our dependency on the Middle East for oil, the frustration over the last three decades at making any serious progress of reducing our oil dependency by decreasing oil consumption and seriously exploring alternative energy sources.

The responses I received from the last column resulted in meetings with several Santa Monica residents, who have come forward and taken personal actions that make a difference in the quest for lessening our dependence on foreign oil and improving our environment. I made mention in my last column of Gov. Schwarzenegger’s pledge to solve our problems by building a “hydrogen highway.” This came about a year after President Bush made reference in his January 2003 State of the Union address to commit $1.2 billion over five years to research the production of hydrogen as a replacement for gasoline in automobiles.

I started thinking back again to the 1970s when long gas lines produced unanimous bipartisan agreement with rhetoric about reducing our demand for foreign oil and developing alternative fuel sources. A trend appeared to follow by people who purchased smaller and more efficient automobiles. What happened to that trend? We are consuming more gasoline with the sale and purchase of less-fuel-efficient vehicles.

According to Ward’s Automotive Reports, V8 engines went into nearly one-third of all passenger vehicles built in North America for sale in the United States last year, the highest percentage since 1985. Each time a V8 engine is selected over a V6 engine, the driver will burn an extra 104 gallons per year with 15,000 miles driven. What about the incredible proliferation of SUVs? During the 1990s, California was forced to look at ways to meet air quality targets set by the Clear Air Act. By 2003, the California Air Resources Board had mandated that 10 percent of all new automobiles sold in California be emission free.

As the auto manufacturers like General Motors plunged into research and development of electric vehicles (EVs), the consumer was given mixed signals. A small number of EVs were produced like the Saturn EV1 (648 produced and all 648 eventually leased). Toyota got into the market with production of RAV4 EVs. Ford put forth its Th!nk Evs. The early critics attacked EVs as being too expensive, with too short of a driving range, and a minimal infrastructure.

There was no concerted effort at marketing the benefits of EVs to the general public: Zero emissions, quiet operation, powerful acceleration, no trips to the gas station, no oil changes, no tune-ups, no transmission. In short order, the automakers started shutting down their assembly lines. One example in point is Toyota. They originally proposed a retail program to span two years. However, within eight months, all 400 of their RAV4 EVs were sold, and the waiting list at dealerships was growing. Toyota reacted by refusing to make any more vehicles to meet customers’ demands. Toyota ended their program 16 months early and justified it by referring to a “lack of demand.”

To make matters worse, the automak-ers took it upon themselves to take the majority of EVs (which were part of a lease program as opposed to outright ownership by the consumer) and send them to “crushers” when turned in at the end of their lease term, so they would be permanently off the road. This process is occurring in spite of loud complaints by customers to either permit them to continue their leases or to sell them outright. Interestingly, our own city has a fleet of 13 EVs with their leases coming to an end. Will we see them get caught up in this ridiculous crushing process?

The real irony here is that most of the current EV customers are incredibly enthusiastic supporters of them. This last week, several Santa Monica residents came by to share their experiences with my husband and me, and allowed us to drive their prize possessions. The two cars that we drove (a RAV4 EV and a neighborhood electric vehicle called a Gem) were great. My husband and I would have purchased the RAV4 EV on the spot if it had been for sale. Unfortunately, none have been made since about December 2002. None are scheduled to be manufactured, and the ones that are going to be coming off lease (you guessed it) are heading to the “crusher” for extinction. What a country.

So what do the automakers and the oil companies have in store for us down the road? In the long run, we are being told to get ready for the “hydrogen highway.” Gov. Schwarzenegger and many others — all the way to the White House in Washington, D.C. — want our alternative source of energy for transportation to come from hydrogen fuel cells. It sounds interesting and clearly more than a little complicated. After looking at numerous studies, I came away with a number of serious concerns, including the following: ■ According to automakers, we are decades away from being able to walk into a dealership and drive away in a fuel cell vehicle. ■ Fuel cell vehicles that operate on hydrogen made with electrolysis consume four times as much electricity per mile as similarly sized EVs. ■ With today’s technology, EVs have twice as much driving range as current fuel cell vehicles. What this focus on hydrogen-powered vehicles seems to be accomplishing is deflecting attention away from energy efficiency in the present.

Hybrid cars, which combine electric motors with small petroleum engines, are presently gaining popularity. Although these hybrids are powered by and require gasoline, they are showing demonstrably better fuel economy than our traditional powered vehicles.

Energy security demands that we shift our energy use away from oil. We have known this for a very long time and have watched politicians and lobbying groups over the last 30-plus years create a real smoke screen. We are looking at a continuation of this petroleum inaction by deflecting attention away from real energy efficiency to a technology of hydrogen fuel cells that keep us on the same course for decades to come. Why not allow people to have access to electric vehicles? Why crush the ones that already exist? Why not support a technology that exists here and now? At the same time, let’s educate motorists and encourage them to switch to and demand more fuel-efficient passenger cars like the hybrids that are now available in growing numbers. The alternative is to find ourselves in a very, very costly mess at all levels for generations to come. (Carole)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 19, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe