SCENTS More things change, more siblings are same
By CAROLE ORLIN
Sibling rivalry reared its ugly head last week. It started out as a fun conversation one evening with friends over dinner and drinks. We were all adults with children, some even with grown children. We started talking about our own horror stories of growing up with our siblings, who were the “meanies.” There was no doubt that we were the innocent victims of these mini-terrorists. The stories were often funny, at least superficially. But, I could tell that even many years later, and often with many miles separating the siblings, past hurts were still very close to the surface.
I found all of this fascinating, because I thought I was the only adult who still was unable to be with my sibling for any amount of time without some ridiculous argument ensuing. One friend recounted being told repeatedly by an older sibling that he had been found in a trash can and was not really part of the family. He believed this story until he was 5 or 6 years old when his parents discovered the problem and set the record straight. He said that there are times that he still feels like he is not part of the family. Another told of the many creative ways her older sibling used to humiliate and embarrass her in front of their friends. Still another told of being left at the subway station, as her brother intentionally boarded the train without her. Luckily some kind stranger brought her home. Talk about fears of abandonment.
The stories went on. Some stories were not funny at all. One friend recounted how her brother used to routinely hold her head under the water until she would almost drown. A couple of people stated they did not argue with their siblings, but they kept their relationships superficial for fear of starting an argument. There was, however, one person there who could not relate at all. He has always had a great relationship with his siblings. Spoil sport. We all had our stories to tell, and a social evening turned into a therapy session of sorts.
It is clear that, even as adults, siblings still know how to push each other’s buttons. At times, mature as we are, we cannot resist doing it every now and then. Haven’t we all found ourselves regressing to that 5-year-old again, after being around our siblings for any amount of time? Who else can make us feel like the powerless kid we once were with just a withering glance or an off-hand remark? These old conflicts can reduce even the most sophisticated adult back to being a child, and prevent us from seeing our siblings and ourselves as we actually are today. I am amazed that, even with my knowledge and life experience, I can turn into the insecure, sniveling tattletale I was as a kid. And there is only one person on this planet can do that to me. I had to tattle — my brother was bigger than me, and it was my only way to fight back, really. No one can damn with feigned praise better than a sibling. Psychologists explain that children under 7 or 8 years old are too egocentric to understand a sibling’s point of view. I guess being around our siblings must somehow transport us back in time to being 7 years old again.
Most of us have had to spend many years with people who may have had very different personalities from us — not to mention annoying habits. But I guess we learned important lessons, like how to be assertive, how to compromise, how to find common ground with someone with whom you have absolutely nothing in common. It’s hard to remember that we are not the only ones who have grown and matured, our siblings have too. Unfortunately, it is often hard to see the forest through the trees. The patterns are established. Rivalry lives on.
I started researching adult sibling rivalry and was surprised to find considerable material on the issue. Of course, sibling rivalry is nothing new. Look at Cain and Abel, Romulus and Remus, Osiris and Seth. Still, I always assumed it was something that we just sort of outgrew. No way. We have the longest and most complicated relationship with our siblings, second only to that with our parents. And the seeds of discord sown at an early age can endure for a lifetime. Unchecked sibling rivalry can harm a person’s self image and damage the relationship between the siblings and others for life. There is often a lingering feeling of grief for the relationship that could have been.
I read a disturbing article by Dr. Vernon Wiehe, professor of social work at the University of Kentucky, titled “Perilous Rivalry: When Siblings Become Abusive.” His study found that as many as 53 out of 100 children abuse a brother or sister — higher than the percentage of adults who abuse children or spouses. He stated that some of this behavior would be considered assault if it was not in the family. Dr. Wiehe went on to discuss the long-term negative effects this unchecked behavior can have on people well into their adult years.
After completing much research, I came to two definite conclusions. First, parents need to take this issue much more seriously than we do. Fortunately, there is a lot of easily accessible information available. Second, as difficult as my rivalries were/are with my own sibling, I know that if I ever needed help he would be there for me, and if he ever needed a kidney I would be first in line for him. I doubt if we will ever truly enjoy each other’s company for any amount of time, but it’s reassuring to know that these negative feelings can be put aside, at least for a while, and we can, when needed, be adults and express our love for each other. We both know the love is there — it’s just difficult to access. (Carole).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 25, 2005. Read the original PDF.