Skip to content

Constitution wasn’t

Published:

written in stone

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY JOHN W. WHITEHEAD

In nominating his longtime aide White House counsel Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court, George W. Bush opined that she “will not legislate from the bench.” Later in defending Miers, Bush emphasized that “a justice must strictly apply the Constitution.” And Leonard Leo of the Federalist Society chimed in that Miers is a “judicial conservative” who will “heed the founders’ vision of the role of courts in our constitutional system.”

While this kind of rhetoric may resonate with some, it makes absolutely no sense logically or historically. It was as if the Constitution, and those who wrote it, were holy scribes merely penning what God dictated to them. To the contrary, our forefathers were certainly not holy, and the Constitution is far from being inerrant.

This is not to say that I do not admire the Constitution, especially as originally amended. Its great principles of rule of law and accountability of the government to the governed have proven to be important bedrocks of American society. Those who fought the American revolution of 1776 understood the need to keep the government in check. This is set forth eloquently in America’s founding document, the Declaration of Independence. But the excessive violence of the French Revolution of 1789 tempered the American revolutionary spirit and gave us the cautious document that became our Constitution.

As we begin to look at the problems that alienate the American people from their government — issues such as taxation, oppressive bureaucratic processes, warring presidents, campaign finances, congressional scandals, over-regulation, governmental expenditures and so on — one realizes that the problem does not always lead back to our elected officials or their policies. The path often leads back to the American Constitution and “the founders’ vision” for our government — which includes a very limited role for the courts. Indeed, if the founders’ vision for the Supreme Court had not been altered early on by Chief Justice John Marshall, it is highly unlikely that the landmark cases protecting our freedoms would have ever been decided.

A casual reading of the Constitution finds that there are various sections that are either out of date, no longer apply, are no longer being used, are being ignored or simply do not work. If we concede that our government, and to a lesser extent our society, emerges from the Constitution, then it becomes the issue. In fact, the more one examines the Constitution, the more it becomes apparent that this is partially the reason why so many feel disinherited by the governmental process.

I urge you to read through the Constitution. Everything that does not make sense, that no longer applies, items that are not being followed, sections that are unreadable or even parts in which you feel we can do better — highlight them with a yellow marker. When you complete the process, look at the document. The average person will have yellowed 15 or more items.

It has been more than 200 years since the Constitution became the law of the land. Since that time, the country and the American people have undergone immense changes that were not and could not have been foreseen by the founders. We are not the same people we were when the Constitution was conceived. Our culture has changed, our ethnic and religious mixes have changed, our technology has transformed the way we live and think, we are more tolerant and our status in the world has drastically altered. The size and structure of our government has grown far beyond its constitutional framework. And few of these systematic alterations to our scheme of government match the original Constitution anymore — a scheme that was developed for 13 isolated colonial states.

We must keep in mind that what was important to the so-called founding fathers — that is, “the founders’ vision” — does not really square with who and what we are today. In fact, those who wrote the Constitution were not advocates of a democracy. They were, to a large extent, a landed aristocracy that was intent on protecting property interests.

The Constitution in many ways has become antiquated. The politicians, especially those in the White House, know this. And the various interest groups, both left and right, know this as well. Unfortunately, they take advantage of the average citizen’s ignorance.

The judges as well know this. That is why every judge, if he or she sits on the bench long enough, eventually, in some way, legislates. Judges are to a certain extent forced to become activists. This is for the simple reason that our Constitution does not address clearly many of the current legal and social issues that we face. This lack of clarity has created a vacuum. And it is why an entire body of judicial interpretations (or cases) has developed in an attempt to explain what the Constitution means. Charles Evans Hughes understood this. In 1907, he remarked, “The Constitution is what the judges say it is.” Hughes later became Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

We are a constitutional government. Thus, it stands to reason that if we have problems with our government, some of these difficulties will be found within the document itself. But we can change this agreement that “we the people” have with the government.

Clearly, the time for constitutional reform is now. If not, the time will come when the Constitution will be so far removed from the realities of society and government that it no longer applies. As a consequence, our government will no longer be restrained by a written Constitution. The next step, thus, will be government without limitation and the destruction of any semblance of democracy.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 27, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe