By CAROLE ORLIN
The last weekend of February marked the one-year anniversary of the end of Southern California’s calamitous grocery strike and lock out. It was the longest lasting strike of its kind, over four and a half months, with more than 59,000 employees on strike, 70,000 affected, and nearly 20 million customers impacted. The strike is history, but the fallout is far from over. There continue to be many angry customers and many distrustful workers. Reports have surfaced of tense relations between employees who struck and strike breakers who were hired back. There has been high staff turnover, employee resentment towards customers who shopped at the stores during the strike, acrimonious feelings between management and returning workers. Workers have voiced dissatisfaction with the few short-term gains that were achieved, and there has been criticism directed at the union for being out of touch with its members. UFCW Local 770 President Rick Icaza had predicted the strike would last no more than two weeks.
It is not reasonable to expect people to give up job security and benefits without a fight. I also realize that the chains were trying to win concessions in order to stay competitive against competitors like Wal- Mart. The entire process was a complicated situation, and there were no apparent winners. It caused me to reflect on what it is like to be a customer at these stores now. One thing that stands out because of the fallout from the strike: It is no longer a pleasant experience to shop at these grocery stores. I am evidently not alone in this view. The combined losses during the actual dispute from the three chains involved, Safeway, Inc. (which owns Vons), Albertson’s, Inc., and Kroger Co. (the parent company of Ralphs) have been estimated at anywhere from $700 million in sales to more than double that amount. Since the dispute ended, the chains have seen their gross profit margins decline allegedly as a result of discounts offered to win back their customers. The LA Times reported last week (“Kroger’s Recovery Is in Slow Checkout Line; Loss Widens,” March 9, 2005, page C1) that Kroger Co., which has been more successful at drawing customers back than its two rivals, had a net loss for the quarter ending Jan. 29, 2005, of more than $675 million. That loss did include a charge of $884 million to write down the value of its Ralphs and Food 4 Less chains.
At the start of the strike, I did not cross the picket line. My action was partially out of loyalty to the workers, and partially out of the desire to not be given dirty looks by the striking workers. Within a short period of time after the strike began, I was not crossing the picket line for another reason. I found that I could get everything I needed, and even some new and interesting items, at other stores. At first, I resented having to drive all the way to Trader Joe’s for cereal, but I soon discovered new cereals there that were more appealing than the ones I could get at the chain stores. What I could not get at Trader Joe’s, I supplemented at Whole Foods, Costco, and even in an emergency, The Farms. Yes, it seems like a lot of stops, when I could just be making one at the chain store, but I have gotten it down to a science. Now, on occasion, I will go to the chain stores for something I cannot get anywhere else.
One negative outcome of the consumer shift away from the chain stores is the fact that business at other stores, like Trader Joe’s, has picked up significantly. Unfortunately, this means longer lines and more difficulty parking. I recently found myself at Trader Joe’s waiting in a long line, starting to feel frustrated, when a staff member came by offering all of us some chocolate peanut butter cups. That little gesture changed our attitudes. It showed the customer that management was aware of our frustration, and although the peanut butter cups did not speed the line up, at least it showed some concern for the customer.
The strike forced me to change my routine, but it was definitely for the best. Was I willing to go back to the chain stores after the strike? Absolutely. However, the atmosphere there now is completely different. The checker whom I had known for three years was kind of cold to me. Has she seen me sneak in on the few occasions I shopped there during the strike? Had they all seen me? I wanted to explain the reason for my transgressions, but I did not know if I would or could be forgiven. One year later, I see this strike as a lose/lose/win situation. I see it as a lose/lose for the chains and the employees, and a win for this consumer.
I would not want to open up old wounds, but the wounds have not yet healed. I would like to see the chains survive, but whenever I shop in one, I get the feeling that survival might be a real issue in the long run. From my limited shopping experiences at the chains since the strike, the stores often seem almost empty. They are now a vast, cold, uninviting, unfriendly place. They seem anachronistic. It is not business as usual there, and attempting to operate as if it is, is not working. People shop at stores for more than the products they sell. We go there for the whole experience, the employees, the energy, the gestalt. Ask any first-year marketing student. I know the grocery stores and their employees are dealing with a lot of varied issues now, but if this issue is not addressed, anything either side might have hoped to gain from the strike will be irrelevant, and grocery chains will go the way of the dinosaurs. (Carole)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 14, 2005. Read the original PDF.