By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R- Tenn.) on Wednesday took to the Senate floor and said: “I do not rise for party, I rise for principle.”
Hogwash. This filibuster battle — on both sides — is all about party. It isn’t at all about principle. If either side cared about principle, they would have found a way to compromise. They would have stepped off their self-constructed pedestals and shown themselves to be worthy of their title “honorable.”
Ever since the 2000 presidential stalemate in Florida, everything has been a “nuclear” debate. This isn’t the first time the political parties have taken each other to task. In fact, that’s all they’ve been doing for five years. Whipping up controversies. Exciting the emotions of the public with their demagoguery. Doesn’t anyone remember that, “Eye for an eye, makes the whole world blind”?
Well, I guess that’s what we’ve got — a bunch of blind politicians leading us in circles.
What’s worse is that we’re living in some of the most unimportant times Americans have ever lived through. But this is not what we’re being told. The daily messages from the parties, our leaders and from the media are that “these times are unprecedented” and that “never in our history have we faced these kinds of dangers or confronted these types of challenges.”
Ridiculous. I wish people would just spend a nominal amount of time reading history. This country has gone through a Revolutionary War, a Civil War, two World Wars and a Great Depression — all before 1950.
Yes, these events all happened before the memories of most people who are commentating, writing and participating in politics today kicked in. In other words, if you don’t know about history, it’s likely you don’t remember these events. And here’s the problem with that. These events were not small. They were huge and they were important.
They are not akin to health insurance rising 12 percent last year (by the way, mine rose 17 percent, so if I wanted to I could be as enraged about this issue as anyone), or the economy only growing by 3.5 percent, or unemployment being at 5.6 percent, or Social Security going bankrupt in 30 years, or even that we have tragically lost more than 1,600 men and women who are serving in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Before you write me nasty e-mails telling me that I am heartless, that I don’t care about today’s problems, or that I am underestimating the threat of terrorism, please just let me give you some of the statistics from another time, so you can try and have some perspective on how fortunate we are to be living now.
During the Civil War, more than 364,000 men who were serving in the military died. During World War II, more than 16 million individuals served in the military and more than 400,000 died. And these were only the American military casualties. World War II brought enormous destruction across all of Europe and into Russia, and of course, the atomic bombs we dropped on Japan decimated entire cities — whole populations. In 1933, at the height of the Great Depression, the unemployment rate in the country hit 27 percent.
Moreover, when you look back on America, it’s miraculous that we’re here at all. As David McCullough just told Newsweek during an interview about his new book on George Washington, 1776: “The fortunes of the United States of America never looked so bleak as they did in 1776 — never. Everything was down to 3,000 men. At key moments, if the wind had blown differently in New York in August or on the Delaware River in December, it would have all been over. I truly believe that.”
This is the kind of perspective that reading history brings. Americans have gone through much worse than what we are experiencing today. Lynchings, Jim Crow laws and Japanese internment camps are just some of the horrors in America’s recent past that have fortunately become history. However, to not know about or understand how severe these historical abuses were or how much pain they brought to the communities and the people who had to endure them commits another abuse. Comparing today’s issues to past struggles is something that only the arrogance and the narcissism that pervades our popular culture would allow.
Here’s The Thing: It’s time for everyone who is engaged in the process — elected officials, pundits, interest groups, activists, party leaders, et al — to read history, find humility, admit some imperfections and begin rethinking how you might contribute. Stop turning every molehill into a mountain to justify your existence and bolster your importance. Recognition comes from achievement, not whining. Greatness overcomes challenges. Pettiness creates obstacles. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles and is teaching this semester at California State University, Channel Islands. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 20, 2005. Read the original PDF.