By EYE ON THE CITY BY ELIZABETH RIEL
What’s the latest threat stalking our city’s residential streets? It’s not road rage. It’s parking rage.
When City Hall first came up with its new plan to sell residential parking permits to businesses, I was willing to give it the benefit of the doubt. But after going to a few city-sponsored community meetings, I can understand why residents are up in arms.
City Hall’s transportation management division’s “pilot program” is not a carefully considered, long-term solution to meet the needs of both the city’s residents and businesses. It’s a temporary, patchwork plan fraught with problems from the outset.
First, the plan is inequitable. It doesn’t really seem fair to say that business employees should be allowed to park in some neighborhoods but not others. Nor does it seem fair to put all the parking burden on the residents who live on streets immediately north and south of the major business corridors.
City Hall did not survey the streets beyond the first permitted blocks to assess whether parking levels might be lower and therefore more suitable for employee permits. Is it too much to ask employees to walk a couple of blocks?
City Hall’s logic is that these first permitted blocks are not yet at “full capacity” — i.e. currently jammed wall-to-wall with cars — so why not pack in some extra cars to really make things cozy? But the reason why residents fought to get these streets permitted in the first place was because they were already experiencing extreme congestion from shoppers and employees — not to mention neighborhood disturbances, increased trash and speeding. Think this plan will solve that? Think again.
Second, City Hall’s plan is unenforceable. The transportation planning folks — all three or so of them — say they will personally contact business permit holders when they receive complaints of abuse and “remind” them of the permit rules. I find it a tiny bit unlikely they would have the time to become parking enforcement officers. The Santa Monica Police Department’s parking enforcement division doesn’t even seem to have the time to do that. When’s the last time you saw a parking enforcement officer checking permits in your neighborhood? I only see those little carts on street cleaning day or stalking the meters.
Third, this plan has no evaluation component or criteria for its success/failure. The burden should be on City Hall to prove that employee permit parking is working well for both residents and businesses. But there is no assessment tool other than the opinion of City Hall’s transportation management division, and of course, public outcry by residents after the fact. Which leads to a larger problem...
It’s easy to get the impression that because City Hall holds neighborhood meetings on various issues that the residents play a key role in shaping proposals and recommendations presented by city staff to the City Council. While that may be true in some cases, in this instance, to say so would be stretching things.
The parking permit meetings seemed to be more of an exercise in frustration for the majority of residents and handful of businesses who attended. People who just wanted their questions answered were met with evasive answers and more often, no answer at all.
Granted, it’s not easy to face a roomful of emotional people, and the way a few residents are reported to have behaved toward the city staff is inexcusable. But a sure-fire way to ignite an angry crowd is to tell people their questions will be answered if they write them down on note cards, and then cherry-pick the five or six easiest questions, ignoring the rest.
And doing things the easy way seems to be what’s happening here. As one resident in the Pico neighborhood asked, “why is this the only plan that was researched or presented? Has the city even researched the need for an alternative employee parking plan?”
When City Hall’s opinion surveys come back and say parking is the No. 3 concern of Santa Monica’s citizens, then why aren’t we taking it more seriously, as opposed to developing different plans and criteria throughout the city? If we hope to solve any of the long-term problems facing Santa Monica, patchwork solutions just won’t cut it. (Elizabeth Riel is a Santa Monica resident. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 26, 2006. Read the original PDF.