Skip to content

Culturally-adapted children get the best of both worlds

Published:

By MARGARET ALTMAN Special to the Daily Press

Question from the parent of a 4-year-old child: I’ve noticed when I watch my child play in day care that many of the Asian children seem to have better self-control than the other kids. Is this part of their early childhood learning experiences?

Answer: Every culture and each society has unique child-rearing practices. These practices are geared towards teaching children how to adapt and how to survive in their own culture. In this expanding and increasingly interactive world, parents can learn from teaching practices that have strengthened specific skills in youngsters from other cultural environments. Parents want their kids to be able to adapt to many kinds of experiences, and to be comfortable and productive in many situations. In order to do this we can look at how other societies teach their children to face adversity, and deal with their feelings.

In a recent study that compared American and Chinese child rearing practices it was found that there were significant differences between these cultures in the way that emotional experiences are talked about and dealt with.

American society, with its individualistic themes, has encouraged parents to delve into the feelings that their children have about emotional events, and to talk about the causes and explanations for emotional events. American parents put the child in a central role when they talk about emotional situations and focus upon their child’s unique feelings.

In the Chinese study population it was found that parents focus more on how the child’s feelings fit into the social norms of the group. It is not that they dismiss the youngster’s emotions but they do tie them into what is expected from the culture. Chinese parents were found to make strong efforts to shape the child’s emotional responses to fit into the family and social group as a whole.

As an example, when a child has become angry with a parent or other adult, the goal is to reestablish the relationship with the adult and teach the child the moral appropriateness of their behavior. In American families, the child’s anger would be the focus of discussion and this feeling would have a high priority in terms of discussion.

The study also found that Chinese parents tend to find a resolution for angry interactions that threaten the solidarity of the family and the social group. American parents are more concerned with helping their kids overcome fear and become strong individuals in this individualistic society.

When we look at these different child rearing practices with an open mind, we can see that it doesn’t have to be an “either or” situation in terms of what parents teach their children in the realm of emotions. The following are several tips for parents who want to enrich their young children’s emotional and social lives. ■Develop a balanced style. Begin to encourage your child to express feelings at appropriate times during the day. Many families have high intensity, emotional de-briefings during meal times and this should be a time of peace, harmony and comfort for everyone. Save the venting sessions for a special time when the focus is on reviewing the day’s experiences. ■Teach sensitivity to others. Encourage your children to pay attention to what other people are feeling by teaching them to notice face expressions, voice tones and body language. Give your child a richer emotional experience by expanding his emotional sensitivity to other people besides himself. ■Develop positive rules for strong feelings. Teach your child that when he is afraid or sad that this is the time to seek adult help and not forge on alone. It is also helpful to explain to children that anger is a “normal” feeling but that it is disruptive to family harmony. Practice resolving angry situations within the family as quickly as possible and strongly discourage any physical or verbal lashing out. (Margaret Altman L.C.S.W. is the author of “Developing Your Child’s Emotional Intelligence” and is in private practice with Dr. A. Korchmarev in Sherman Oaks.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe