By Beth Solomon
WASHINGTON — In “The Russia House,” a Glasnost-era spy movie based on the book by John LeCarre, Sean Connery and Michelle Pfeiffer outwit American and British intelligence services to protect something more precious than political ideology — love.
Set in Russia in the 1980s, the film is a walk down Red Menace Memory Lane — grim apparatchiks hiding around every corner, tiny East German autos spewing black smoke, gray tenement blocs, sulfurous air, and everyone complaining about the food as they chug vodka and smoke like chimneys.
Ah, the good old days. Yes, the threat of Communist domination looks almost inviting when you compare it to today’s evening news. Nuclear annihilation, ICBMs, “two minutes to midnight” and the Cuban Missile Crisis might not be your idea of a Sunday picnic.
But how about dirty bombs in subways, millions of radicals wielding grenade launchers shouting “Death to America,” and a global transportation network that makes loose nukes easier to get in many places than Hostess Twinkies.
Welcome to the 21st Century. You are free to move about the … bomb shelter?
How did we get here from there? The 1964 documentary “Point of Order,” a gritty black and white look at the Army-McCarthy hearings of 1954, offers some surprising comparisons to today’s technicolor politics.
McCarthyism threw many Americans into a maze of fear, paranoia and hate. McCarthy convinced much of America that the threat of Communism was everywhere. He said individual evil-doers could be eliminated to destroy the menace. He said we must all be vigilant. He had a list.
The only problem was the list was used to destroy people for holding political views that differed from McCarthy’s. McCarthyism became a weapon in American politics that was used to destroy dissent.
McCarthy was fond of saying that the trouble with Communists was that they had no freedom. “A Communist is not free — he’s not a free agent,” McCarthy said. That characteristic put America at risk.
Funny, but that’s the same argument our current ideological leader, President George Bush, uses to justify the War on Terror and the War on Iraq.
Our duty, he says, is to spread freedom — what he thinks is freedom — to everyone on earth. In fact, Bush says, it’s our duty to God.
At his recent press conference, President Bush explained it this way: “Freedom is the Almighty’s gift to every man and woman in this world. And as the greatest power on the face of the Earth, we have an obligation to help the spread of freedom.”
With bombs, guns and tanks, that is — if the natives don’t get the concept right away.
It’s insulting. It’s rude. And it’s terribly frightening. Especially when those words are beamed live to other fundamentalists who do their violence in the name of a competing God.
Freedom is a great idea, don’t get me wrong. But the concept of freedom that was used by McCarthy and seems to motivate George Bush can become a dangerous ideology — or an immoral cause for war. Imposing it on others should carry a warning: “Could be foolhardy. Could be fatal.”
And sure enough, today’s post-Cold War ideology, including a “manifest destiny” policy of global freedom, has attracted a hail of bullets from many of those we’re trying to “save.”
When you’re imposing your beliefs behind the barrel of a gun, fundamentalism — no matter what it’s motivations — is a dangerous thing.
To ignore the humanity of the people one is trying to save — or those caught in the crossfire — is as wrong in Iraq as it is wrong at the World Trade Center.
Which is not lost on those angry young men with rocket launchers... or their mothers, sisters and wives.
The Army’s special counsel, Joseph N. Welch, pierced the veil of McCarthy’s ideological plague when he famously asked, “Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last? Have you left no sense of decency?”
The same question is relevant today. (Beth Solomon is a Left Coast writer based in Washington, D.C. who).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 28, 2004. Read the original PDF.