Dear Dorie: My husband and I are considering pulling our 2-year-old out of preschool. I am a stay-at-home mom and although I need the time off, it is not an absolute necessity for him to go to school. He attended summer camp at the same preschool and did great. Now that the school year has started and he is in a different room, he is telling us that he does not want to be there.
In the mornings, he tries to convince me to not take him to school. He is quite verbal and smart and has figured me out completely. My gut feeling is that he resents all the structure of school, and the lack of one-on-one attention. Although he has a little sister, I have always worked hard to make them feel special and loved individually. So, my son would rather be home. A compliment of sorts, no doubt, but I feel that getting a taste of procedure, rules and socialization is of vital importance to children. My husband is afraid that an early negative experience with school might turn him against academics in the future. Is he right? Please help us make that best decision for our son.
Dear mom, Let me get this right, he has a new baby sister and started a new program in a new room with a new teacher and a new group of toddlers and now he wants to stay home. I would too. His world is full of confusion and anxiety, and he’s trying to make sense of it.
You’re right. Preschool at 2 years and 10 months is not a necessity but I wouldn’t recommend pulling him out of a program at this point. The last thing he needs is more confusion. I would, however, arrange to speak with the teachers and program director immediately. They may have — and should have — some insight into his resistance. It could be typical transition/separation anxiety or something more complicated. Their response to your concerns should be respectful and thorough. An observation plan should be made with regular follow-up on his progress.
Outside the school, I would attempt to “connect” him to his new classmates. This is where play dates come in. Talk to the other parents at drop-off or pick-up and invite them to come over. Start with two hours at the most and watch what happens. True interactive play dates will come later. That is not your goal — you’re just trying to help him connect with his new classroom buddies.
Now, when it comes to structure, procedure, rules and academic experience, slow down, we’re talking preschool here. The goal is to prepare your child to enter kindergarten ready to learn, not have him read Shakespeare next year. Your program should provide an integrated and age-appropriate curriculum, a well-educated staff, state license, which is required, and preferably, an NAEYC accreditation. Most importantly, a safe, nurturing environment where children can learn through their play is key. If this doesn’t describe your program, start looking for a better one.
Tell you husband that I know of no studies that correlate a negative preschool experience with future academic performance. But any negative preschool experience is worth reviewing in a variety of contexts: Social, emotional, physical, as well as cognitive.
Here’s the bright side: Separation anxiety means your son has already learned to care about you and is aware the he is separate from you. He just needs more experience in trusting that you come back. Hang in there and good luck. (Dorie Meek is director of the Infant & Family Support Program, provided by Saint John’s Health Center in partnership with the Santa Monica- Malibu Unified School District. Meek answers questions concerning children ages birth to 5 years old. Submit your questions to “Dear Dorie” at, or call (310) 452-6132; fax (310) 452-6392).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 5, 2004. Read the original PDF.